Newfoundland and Labrador's Information and Privacy Commissioner recommended releasing neutral legal-retainer records while preserving privilege over litigation bills in Report A-2026-035, dated October 20, 2026.

The Department of Justice and Public Safety withheld outside-counsel records requested June 3, citing continuing government strategy work. The requester pointed to similar information disclosed in 2024. After informal resolution failed, the department supplied unredacted records for investigation.

Legal bills are presumptively privileged unless disclosure cannot reasonably reveal protected communications. This requester's involvement in the lawsuit meant amounts, dates and cumulative totals could reveal confidential communications, even though the litigation had ended.

Retainer letters, a sample billing form, and lawyers' names and hourly rates revealed no case-specific advice or work allocation. Equivalent information had been disclosed in 2024. The commissioner recommended disclosure within ten days of the report’s release, with signatures redacted, while withholding the remainder.

Broadband records

In Report A-2026-024, dated August 31, 2026, the commissioner recommended disclosure of 233 pages concerning Xplore's rural Internet project.

The Department of Jobs, Growth and Rural Development initially withheld 247 pages under intergovernmental-relations and third-party-business exceptions. During investigation, it abandoned the latter ground and agreed to release 14 pages, but continued withholding the rest.

Records included Xplore's federal agreement, project descriptions, route maps and a presentation. The province provided financing but was not a party to the agreement.

The department relied on confidentiality provisions and federal reluctance to disclose. However, the agreement preserved access-law requirements and exceptions to confidentiality. General concerns about future intergovernmental trust did not show how disclosure of these specific records would cause the required harm.

Publicity since 2022 also weakened its position. It failed its evidentiary burden. Disclosure remained subject to removing signatures and similar personal information.

Different safeguards, shared accountability

The Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act, 2015 permits withholding a public body's privileged information under section 30. Separately, section 40(2)(g) says disclosing financial and other details of government supply contracts is not an unreasonable invasion of personal privacy.

For the intergovernmental-harm exception in section 34(1)(a), anticipated harm must be reasonably grounded. Section 43 places the burden on a public body defending an access refusal.

Under sections 49 and 50, department heads must respond within ten business days after receiving a recommendation. Refusing recommended disclosure requires a court application within that period. A recommendation’s publication does not, by itself, show that records were released.