
A dispute about the amount of employment-insurance benefits must follow the administrative review process rather than revive a court challenge to benefit denials that have already been reversed, the Federal Court of Appeal has ruled.
In Detre v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FCA 167, decided October 5, the court dismissed an appeal by Nicholas Detre without costs. At the same time, it expressed concern about the procedure that led the Federal Court to dismiss his original application as moot.
Eligibility decisions had already been reversed
Detre had sought judicial review of decisions that he was not entitled to EI benefits. The Canada Employment Insurance Commission later reconsidered those decisions in his favour, and he received money for both claims. The Federal Court therefore dismissed his application on February 21, 2025, because the original dispute no longer required a decision.
On appeal, Detre argued that a calculation error had left him with only 87 per cent of the benefits he believed were payable. The appeal court did not decide whether that calculation was right. The reconsideration decisions were separate decisions, outside the proceedings before it.
Justice Vanessa Rochester, writing for a unanimous panel, explained that asking for a declaration did not by itself prevent the original case from becoming moot. Nor could the court use the existing case to bypass the administrative remedies available for the new calculation dispute.
Possible extension, not a court-ordered recalculation
The parties agreed that the deadline for seeking administrative redetermination had passed, but the Commission retained discretion to extend it. The court expressed the hope that the Commission would carefully consider Detre’s reasons for the delay, his circumstances and his eventual success in obtaining benefits.
That observation was not an order extending the deadline or awarding additional benefits. The judgment left any renewed calculation challenge to the administrative process.
Concern about the lack of a formal motion
The court was troubled by how mootness had been raised below. Detre had applied for permission to amend his judicial-review application. The government raised mootness in its responding materials rather than bringing a formal motion to dismiss. Detre then had to address the issue in reply, without an opportunity to prepare a full responding record.
The appeal record did not contain those reply submissions. As a result, the panel could not determine whether Detre had received a meaningful opportunity to respond and did not find that procedural fairness had been breached. It nevertheless said a formal motion would have been preferable.
Even if unfairness had been established, the court said the outcome was inevitable: the original eligibility dispute was moot, while a court challenge to the calculation remained premature until the administrative process had run its course.
The panel also refused to admit fresh evidence about the benefit amount. Such evidence could not decide the narrow question on appeal, which was whether the Federal Court had made a reviewable error by dismissing the original case as moot. Both the appeal and the fresh-evidence motion were dismissed without costs.



