
Commercial beekeepers have lost an appeal seeking compensation for alleged economic losses caused by restrictions on importing honeybee packages from the continental United States.
In Paradis Honey Ltd. v. Canada (Agriculture and Agri-Food), 2026 FCA 150, delivered on September 4, 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the dismissal of the negligence class action. The Court found that the beekeepers had not established a sufficiently close and direct relationship with the Canadian Food Inspection Agency to support a private duty of care.
The unanimous Court dismissed the appeal without awarding costs against the appellants. It did not need to decide their separate challenge to the trial judge’s finding that they had not proved recoverable loss or damages.
Replacing colonies after winter losses
The representative plaintiffs were Paradis Honey Ltd., Honeybee Enterprises Ltd. and Rocklake Apiaries Ltd. They brought the action on behalf of commercial beekeepers, alleging economic harm from the continued restriction on U.S. bee-package imports after 2006.
A package contains a small colony, including a queen. The beekeepers argued that importing packages was the most efficient and least expensive way to replace colonies lost through winter. Importing a queen with a few attendant bees is a different practice.
Canada began restricting U.S. honeybee imports in the 1980s in response to disease and pest concerns. Regulations introduced in 2004 allowed queen bees and their attendants but not packages. When those regulations expired in 2006, the government continued the practical prohibition on packages by refusing import permits under the Health of Animals Regulations. Queen-bee permits continued to be issued.
The litigation concerned the CFIA’s maintenance of that prohibition and its consideration of ways to reduce import risks. The Court’s account covered risk assessments in 1994, 2003 and 2013. Because the finding that the 2013 assessment investigated mitigation measures was not challenged, this appeal’s factual scope was limited to the period before that assessment was finalized.
Surviving an early challenge was not a finding of liability
The action began in December 2012. In 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal allowed it to proceed after the Federal Court had struck the claim. At that early stage, the question was whether the pleaded allegations, assumed to be true, plainly disclosed no viable claim.
The action was later certified for a class covering people in Canada who kept more than 50 bee colonies at a time for commercial purposes since December 31, 2006. After a common-issues trial, however, the Federal Court dismissed the action in 2024.
The latest appeal emphasized the difference between those stages. The 2015 decision did not finally establish a duty of care or prove the alleged interactions with government officials. At trial, those allegations had to be tested against evidence, and the pleadings and certified issues had also changed.
The duty claimed was broader than one risk assessment
The beekeepers argued that the trial judge had wrongly expanded a narrow duty to identify risk-mitigation options into a generalized duty to protect their economic interests.
The appeal court disagreed. The certified issue asked whether the defendants owed a duty not to be negligent in maintaining or enforcing the practical import prohibition. Before trial, the parties added language including a duty to identify mitigation options in the 2003 and 2013 assessments.
That addition did not replace the broader issue. Considering mitigation was part of the alleged duty, not a separate formulation that displaced the rest of the claim. The trial judge had therefore addressed the issue as certified and amended, rather than inventing a new one.
Foreseeable harm did not establish a close legal relationship
The negligence analysis required both reasonably foreseeable harm and proximity: a relationship close enough to justify imposing a private legal duty. If that initial duty were established, a court would then consider whether broader policy reasons should negate it.
The CFIA knew that restricting imports could increase commercial beekeepers’ costs. But foreseeable economic harm was not enough. The decisive problem was the absence of the required relationship.
The Court upheld findings that the CFIA’s communications stayed within normal regulatory activity. Officials sought input on regulatory changes, discussed permit applications, attended industry meetings and communicated with national representatives. These exchanges did not establish a special relationship distinct from the agency’s relationship with others affected by its work.
Many communications were initiated by the beekeepers. Responses, where established, generally explained the agency’s mandate, framework or submission processes. Claims that officials had undertaken specific actions were not accepted on the evidence, and those factual findings were not challenged on appeal. The record did not establish reliance or expectations supporting the claimed private duty.
The Court distinguished this broad regulatory work from safety-inspection cases involving more direct relationships with a discrete group. Consulting an industry helps a regulator obtain information and act in the public interest; consultation alone does not create a duty to protect that industry’s private interests.
No blanket immunity for regulators
The Court agreed that the Health of Animals Act and its regulations did not themselves create a private duty to protect individual beekeepers’ economic interests. Their purpose was protecting animal and human health. Regulatory impact statements could help interpret regulations but could not override their language or create the missing relationship.
It nevertheless cautioned against treating legislation as implicitly foreclosing a duty at the initial stage of the analysis. Broader policy conflicts belong at the second stage, where the government bears the burden of showing why an otherwise established duty should be denied.
That distinction did not change the result. The beekeepers failed to establish proximity through their interactions with the CFIA. The Court therefore did not need to decide the trial judge’s alternative policy-immunity findings or the damages issue.
The ruling does not mean that regulators can never owe private duties or face damages. The Court expressly treated the question as fact-specific. Here, the evidence showed ordinary industry consultation rather than the special relationship needed to sustain the negligence claim.



