
The City of Richmond was ordered to create and disclose a record showing its total legal costs for each of two concluded appeals involving B.C. Utilities Commission decisions.
In Order F26-77, 2026 BCIPC 96, dated September 1, adjudicator David S. Adams considered requests from a former commission member. The applicant sought aggregate amounts, not invoices or descriptions of legal work.
Legal-fee information is presumptively privileged. Richmond argued that related issues remained live and that a knowledgeable observer could infer confidential communications from the amounts.
Adams found that both appeals had ended and the contemplated future matters did not make them ongoing. The totals contained no dates, work descriptions or billing patterns. Even a well-informed observer could not reasonably infer privileged communications from those lump sums, rebutting the presumption on these facts.
Although Richmond did not already hold a record stating the totals, it could readily create one from its invoices and was required to do so. The order set October 16 as the compliance deadline; the reasons do not establish subsequent compliance.



