Bell Canada was ordered to refund Quebecor for certain pole-related corrective-work charges, but Quebecor failed to shift the separate costs of moving its own equipment onto the incumbent carriers.

The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission drew that distinction in Telecom Decision CRTC 2026-199, Quebecor Media Inc. – Application to clarify Telecom Regulatory Policy 2023-31 and certain related decisions and orders, issued August 6, 2026.

The ruling makes the invoice date decisive when determining which tariff applies to a support-structure access application. It required Bell to remove corrective-work charges from invoices issued since January 28, 2025, and reimburse Quebecor within 30 days for those charges already collected.

Two kinds of work, two kinds of expense

The dispute concerned poles and strands used to support telecommunications lines. Incumbent local exchange carriers control infrastructure that competing companies need to attach their own facilities.

A 2023 policy distinguished make-ready work, required because a company wants to add equipment, from corrective work needed to bring an existing structure or its attachments into compliance with construction and safety standards.

The policy assigned corrective-work costs to incumbent carriers, including Bell, SaskTel and TELUS. Revised tariffs implementing that distinction took effect on January 28, 2025. Applications processed before the change remained subject to the previous tariff.

Quebecor, acting for Videotron and Freedom Mobile, asked what it meant for an application to have been processed. It also sought a broader interpretation under which incumbents would pay costs directly associated with corrective work, including moving another carrier's attachments.

Accepting an estimate did not settle the tariff

Quebecor argued that an application was not processed until the permit had been issued and the related charges billed. Rogers and three Quebec regional county municipalities supported its position.

Bell argued that the substantive steps mattered: assessment, inspection, engineering and acceptance of a cost estimate. TELUS likewise treated acceptance of the estimate as a binding commercial commitment and warned that an invoice-based rule would create uncertainty and retroactivity.

The commission rejected that approach. An applicant seeking access before the tariff changed could not insist that corrective-work charges disappear from an estimate. Accepting that estimate did not complete the work, issue the permit or fix the final bill.

The commission also noted that incumbents had known since 2023 that corrective-work costs should not fall on attaching carriers. Following the revised tariff therefore implemented an established determination rather than creating unexpected obligations.

An invoice provided an objective date that both sides could verify. Once the revised tariffs were in force, allowing an incumbent to continue charging for corrective work would contradict those tariffs. The interpretation applied to all incumbent support-structure service tariffs, although the refund direction specifically concerned Bell and Quebecor.

Carriers remain responsible for their own facilities

Quebecor's second request was unsuccessful. It argued that replacing a pole should make the incumbent responsible for directly related relocation, transfer and engineering expenses, whether or not a new permit application triggered the work.

Bell and TELUS said the existing model required each company to bear costs associated with its own facilities. Bell's support-structure licence agreement placed responsibilities for moving and maintaining an attaching carrier's equipment on that carrier.

The commission acknowledged that unexpected relocation costs could burden competitors and be difficult to anticipate. But those expenses had not been included in the cost studies supporting approved rates. Reassigning them would require allowing incumbents to seek recovery through new studies, while estimating the costs would be difficult because carriers use different equipment.

The reasons also identified existing exceptions in practice. Bell moves facilities overlashed to its strands without an additional charge, while TELUS includes moving cable bundles in tariff-covered maintenance. These arrangements did not establish a general obligation to pay every attaching carrier's relocation expenses.

The commission was concerned that additional obligations could discourage preventive maintenance. Incumbents already bore most corrective-work costs, making it unlikely, in the commission's assessment, that they would initiate such work for anti-competitive reasons.

The resulting rule preserves separate responsibilities: incumbents pay for corrective work on support structures, while attaching carriers remain responsible for relocating, transferring and engineering their own facilities. That allocation applies regardless of whether a permit application prompted the corrective work.

The decision does not state a total refund amount or establish that reimbursement has occurred.