
The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission refused to reopen Bell Mobility's long-running dispute with Videotron over permanent roaming, finding that Bell had not established grounds to overturn a decision encouraging the companies to negotiate.
The commission acknowledged one error in its earlier reasoning: it had invoked a privacy objective without evidence of a privacy concern. It concluded that the mistake did not affect the outcome.
The ruling is Telecom Decision CRTC 2026-175, Bell Mobility Inc. – Application for the review, rescission, and variance of a 25 May 2022 letter decision entitled Bell Mobility Inc. – Application for various orders regarding Videotron Ltd.'s use of Bell Mobility's wholesale roaming service, issued July 17, 2026.
Dispute concerned how to measure permanent roaming
Wholesale roaming lets another carrier's customers use an incumbent's wireless network on an incidental basis. Bell's approved tariff prohibited permanent roaming but did not prescribe a numerical threshold for deciding when use crossed that line.
In a 2020 decision, the commission found that Videotron had not complied with the tariff because of technical issues. It also found that Videotron had otherwise taken reasonable measures and that there was no proof it was reselling wireless services through roaming on Bell's network.
The commission prevented suspension of Videotron's roaming service, required corrective measures and expected the companies to exchange information and work toward a mutually acceptable threshold.
Bell brought another application in 2021, alleging that Videotron's screening method allowed permanent roaming and was inconsistently applied. A May 25, 2022 letter decision rejected that application and encouraged good-faith negotiations, with staff-assisted mediation available.
Bell sought reconsideration in August 2022. It requested remedial orders and an administrative monetary penalty, alleging legal and factual errors. TELUS generally supported Bell's position; Videotron defended the existing approach.
Tariff enforcement did not remove regulatory discretion
The reconsideration test required Bell to establish substantial doubt about the earlier decision's correctness, such as an error, a fundamental change in circumstances or a failure to consider a basic principle.
Bell argued that the commission had a duty to enforce its binding tariff rather than treat intervention as optional. It also said sending the companies back to negotiations amounted to improperly refraining from regulation and contradicted earlier commitments to resolve roaming disputes.
The commission distinguished setting a regulatory framework from intervening in every dispute. Section 47 of the Telecommunications Act requires it to exercise its powers consistently with statutory policy objectives, but does not compel action in all cases. Subsection 48(1) preserves discretion to inquire into matters under the relevant part of the Act.
The commission had already approved rates and conditions and left certain operational matters, including a methodology for identifying permanent roaming, for the parties to agree. It also relied on section 60, which allows it to grant relief different from what an applicant requests.
Bell did not establish a discriminatory advantage
Bell argued that Videotron's treatment of low-use roamers gave its customers an improper advantage over customers of other wholesale providers. It also suggested that suspended Videotron customers might otherwise have moved to competitors, including Bell.
The commission said a reconsideration application was not the proper forum for new positions based on facts already available in the original proceeding. It nevertheless addressed the substance to clarify the parties' obligations.
Bell had not supplied the comparative evidence needed to establish a preference. In particular, it had not shown that Videotron's screening rules were more favourable than mechanisms used by other wholesale customers. The tariffs generally prohibited permanent roaming without prescribing thresholds, and carriers could negotiate their own arrangements.
Negotiation expectations survived the challenge
Bell said it had negotiated in good faith and challenged the lack of a stated standard for deciding whether it had done enough. The commission replied that earlier decisions and dispute-resolution guidance had communicated an expectation of reasonable efforts before seeking regulatory intervention.
Its appendix rejected related arguments about precedent, mediation and characterization of the dispute. It also clarified that emphasizing an expectation did not make it a binding rule with the force of law.
The commission accepted that its reference to protecting privacy was an error of mixed fact and law because the earlier record raised no privacy concern. But the error did not create substantial doubt about the result, so the commission declined to reconsider the remedies or impose Bell's requested penalty.
The July ruling reiterated the expectation that Bell and Videotron negotiate appropriate thresholds and monitoring mechanisms. It did not establish that the companies had subsequently reached an agreement.
A later October 22 tariff order, Telecom Order CRTC 2026-276, addressed Bell's roaming-rate negotiation process and access to the Bell-TELUS shared network. That separate order did not decide the permanent-roaming allegations at issue in this reconsideration.



