
The Canada Energy Regulator has approved a four-year toll settlement for TransCanada PipeLines Limited’s Mainline, rejecting two First Nations’ request for a further hearing while leaving their potential compensation claims undecided.
The Commission’s July 9, 2026 letter decision, File 6913083, accepted the 2027–2030 agreement as filed. Order TG-005-2026 implements firm-service tolls from January 1, 2027 through December 31, 2030 and continues specified service and renewal provisions.
Aroland First Nation and Ginoogaming First Nation argued that the agreement failed to account for the Mainline’s ongoing effects on their traditional territories. The Commission concluded that they had not shown how this toll decision would adversely affect their constitutionally protected rights or a commercial interest in the settlement. It expressly made no finding on whether they were entitled to a revenue stream or compensation in another proceeding.
Fixed tolls and commercial support
The Mainline transports natural gas from the Alberta–Saskatchewan border through Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario into part of Quebec. TCPL negotiated the settlement with its Mainline Tolls Task Force, a forum for parties with commercial interests in the pipeline’s tolls and services.
The agreement fixes the negotiated tolls at the same level as the 2022–2026 tolls, rather than deriving them from a forecast cost-of-service model for the new period. It retains mechanisms for sharing actual cost and revenue variances between TCPL and customers, as well as market-driven service and separate adjustment accounts for the Western Mainline and Eastern Triangle. It also introduces changes concerning incentive sharing and capacity-growth capital.
The task force’s vote supported the package: a majority of parties taking a position voted in favour and none cast a strong-opposition vote. Eight shippers filed supporting letters. No shipper, potential shipper or other commercial party raised a concern with the settlement.
That support mattered but did not automatically settle the regulatory question. The Commission’s guidelines require a fair negotiation process for interested parties, adequate public information, and an agreement that does not prevent the regulator from considering the public interest. Sections 230 and 235 of the Canadian Energy Regulator Act require just and reasonable tolls without unjust discrimination.
The First Nations’ objections
The Nations said the toll framework did not reflect the true costs of operating the Mainline because it omitted a dedicated revenue stream, such as an Indigenous property tax, for affected First Nations. They linked that request to ongoing impacts from operations and maintenance work and argued that a contemporary approach to reconciliation should inform the public-interest assessment.
They also challenged their exclusion from the task force and negotiations, sought access to negotiation documents, and asked the Commission to reject the agreement and establish a hearing. Their consultant had presented proposed revenue-sharing models to the task force in November 2024, but the Nations said that did not give them a fair opportunity to participate.
TCPL responded that those claims belonged outside a negotiated-tolls proceeding. It said the settlement would not prevent recovery through tolls of costs arising from any entitlement later established in an appropriate forum.
Why no additional hearing was required
The Commission found it reasonable to exclude the Nations from the commercial negotiation process in this case. Neither was a shipper or potential shipper, and neither demonstrated that it contributed traffic, paid tolls or had obligations under the tariff. Their claimed future entitlement to compensation did not, on this record, make them interested parties under the settlement guidelines.
The Commission separately examined Indigenous rights. It found that approving the settlement authorized no physical changes to the pipeline or land and would not prevent the Nations from pursuing claims elsewhere. Applying the distinction between a new decision’s effects and historical grievances, it concluded that the Nations had not demonstrated an adverse effect from this approval that triggered the duty to consult.
It distinguished Kebaowek First Nation, which addressed the content of consultation in a nuclear-facility licensing case, from the threshold question of whether consultation was triggered here. It also found that the Nations had not explained how other authorities or the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act required a different process for this particular settlement.
The reasons acknowledged separate litigation and a CER complaint concerning operations and maintenance. Those matters were not adjudicated in the toll decision. If another forum established an amount payable to the Nations, the Commission said TCPL would remain obligated to pay it regardless of the settlement’s structure.
Public information was sufficient
The Commission accepted the public record’s explanation of the negotiations, agreement provisions and toll calculations. It did not require disclosure of all commercially sensitive negotiation material to assess whether the resulting tolls were reasonable.
Finding the package consistent with the guidelines and statutory requirements, it declined further process and approved it without modification. The ruling establishes the next toll framework; it does not determine the merits of the Nations’ separate compensation claims.



