
Manitoba’s Court of King’s Bench rejected a request for withheld school-division records, finding that internal advice and third-party privacy protections applied.
Justice Suche dismissed the application in Attallah v. St. James-Assiniboia School Division et al., 2026 MBKB 92, decided June 30. The division had released more than 500 documents but withheld some information in ten records.
The applicant argued that communications from a principal to employees were directions, not advice protected by the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. The judge held that advice takes different forms: coming from a superior does not automatically remove protection.
The records did not fall within exceptions for instructions or guidelines, or reasons given when exercising statutory authority.
Confidential third-party information also justified withholding. However, the judge rejected suggestions that disclosure would expose parent-council correspondents to harassment or reveal highly sensitive information. Those findings were unnecessary to sustain confidentiality.
No costs were awarded. Separately, the parties agreed that the division would return the applicant’s $510 filing fee.



