A Newfoundland and Labrador tenant failed to obtain another rent reduction over mice after the tribunal found the landlord had taken all reasonable remedial steps.

The June 26, 2026 decision 26-0426-NL distinguished an earlier ruling involving unresolved water leaks and other repairs. Good-faith attempts alone had not satisfied the maintenance obligation in that earlier dispute, but the adjudicator said those comments did not impose an unachievable standard.

For the mouse problem, the landlord had filled holes and repeatedly retained pest-control services, including traps and outdoor bait stations. The tenant sought repair orders and a further $315 monthly reduction.

The tribunal found the tenant’s expert communications were hypothetical and came from people who had not inspected the building. The evidence did not establish a specific additional measure the landlord should take.

The new claim was dismissed. The decision did not eliminate the landlord’s maintenance duty or announce that hiring a pest-control company always discharges it; the result turned on the steps taken and the evidence presented.