The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission upheld reductions to participation-cost claims by three organizations representing Deaf and Deaf-Blind people, rejecting arguments that its treatment of preparation time and follow-up questions breached accessibility obligations and procedural fairness.

In Telecom Decision CRTC 2026-114, Applications to review and vary Telecom Orders 2025-97, 2025-100, and 2025-102, issued June 1, 2026, the commission left the earlier awards unchanged. The applications concerned reimbursement for participating in the original review of video relay service, not reconsideration of the service's policy requirements.

Most participation costs had been awarded

The May 2025 orders awarded $75,772.20 to the Deaf Wireless Canada Consultative Committee, $102,285.16 to the Deaf-Blind Planning Committee and $90,711.05 to the Canadian National Society of the Deaf-Blind.

The commission reduced or excluded $33,797.75, $18,611.80 and $9,143.95 from their respective claims. Two categories were central: time beyond 24 hours for preparing a costs application, and expenses incurred answering requests for information about the costs claims themselves.

The organizations sought full recovery. They also wanted clarification that reasonably incurred accessibility-related expenses and preparation time were generally eligible, and that fixed hourly caps would not be imposed without notice and process.

To reopen the awards, they had to demonstrate substantial doubt about the earlier decisions' correctness. Relevant grounds included legal or factual error, a fundamental change in circumstances, failure to consider a basic principle or the introduction of a new principle.

Groups challenged accessibility and fairness analysis

The applicants argued that the commission had imposed an unauthorized, predetermined 24-hour ceiling without notice. They said some rejected expenses involved specialized accessibility work and American Sign Language interpretation needed to consult legal counsel, rather than merely answering administrative questions.

They relied on equality rights, human-rights and accessibility legislation, the federal telecommunications policy directions and the commission's accessibility commitments. In their view, the reductions failed to accommodate their needs and risked discouraging meaningful public-interest participation.

The Public Interest Advocacy Centre supported the concerns about barriers and future participation. The Canadian Telecommunications Association maintained that the commission had applied established rules and considered the claims individually.

Commission found its existing approach had been followed

The commission recognized that its discretion under section 56 of the Telecommunications Act had to respect Charter equality values, non-discrimination, accommodation and accessibility obligations. It also stressed responsibility for the reasonableness of awards paid by participating telecommunications companies.

It found that the earlier orders had expressly considered the organizations' reliance on interpretation and need for additional time. Those considerations were reflected in the amounts awarded, including preparation costs.

The groups had claimed 90, 150 and 64 hours respectively to prepare and submit their costs applications. The commission said those amounts substantially exceeded comparable past claims. Its review of the preceding seven years supported allowing 24 hours in these cases, with no evidentiary basis for a higher amount.

Although its guidelines did not prescribe an explicit hourly maximum, they warned that excessive claims could be reduced. The factors included the complexity and volume of material, participants' responsibilities and expertise, duplicated submissions, and time claimed or awarded in similar proceedings.

The commission therefore rejected the claim that it had introduced a new approach without notice. Its reasoning concerned the assessment of these applications, rather than announcing a new universal 24-hour rule.

Follow-up questions were distinguished from substantive participation

The commission accepted that reasonable preparation of a costs application could be connected sufficiently to participation in the main proceeding to justify reimbursement.

It drew a different conclusion about answering questions on the costs applications. Those requests allowed the organizations to explain and adjust their claims, rather than contribute to the underlying video relay review. The commission found the connection insufficient for reimbursement.

It also said its accessibility plan and progress report addressed interpretation at hearings and translation of informational videos. Those commitments did not establish eligibility for interpretation expenses associated with the separate costs-claim process.

Later funding reform applies prospectively

On August 7, the commission issued Telecom Regulatory Policy CRTC 2026-201, increasing reimbursable professional-service rates by 45.44 per cent and introducing a $75,000 limit per applicant, per proceeding for costs applications filed after that date.

The policy allows requests above the threshold with pre-approval in proceedings whose notices of consultation set intervention periods of at least 90 days. It preserves the requirement that claimed expenses be necessarily and reasonably incurred.

Those prospective changes did not reopen the three earlier awards upheld in the June decision.