
The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission rejected Fibernetics' bid to connect a competing transport provider inside a Rogers facility in Calgary, despite finding that Rogers' connection rules gave it an advantage over its customer.
The majority concluded that the disadvantage was not undue or unreasonable. Commissioner Bram Abramson dissented, arguing that Rogers had not adequately justified the extra construction and switching costs imposed on a rival provider.
The dispute was decided in Telecom Decision CRTC 2026-107, Fibernetics Corporation – Application for relief regarding undue preference by Rogers Communications Canada Inc. relating to third-party Internet access interconnection, issued May 28, 2026.
A half-kilometre gap complicated a switch
Fibernetics used Rogers' third-party Internet access service and its backhaul transport service. It wanted to switch the transport connection to TELUS, which already had fibre inside Rogers' head-end facility.
Rogers required the new connection to be made at its designated outdoor meeting point about half a kilometre away. Fibernetics said extending fibre to that location would involve construction costs and take at least 32 weeks, delaying the savings available from the competing service.
Fibernetics sought access inside the facility, additional time to proceed with its service application and reimbursement of Rogers' backhaul fees from October 16, 2024 until cancellation. Carry Telecom, the Competitive Network Operators of Canada, Quebecor and TekSavvy supported the application.
Rogers relied on its approved tariff, which required customers to connect at designated points. It said the head-end lacked the space, equipment and security arrangements needed for the requested access and that it was not obliged to provide third-party co-location there.
A disadvantage was established, but the majority accepted it
Under subsection 27(2) of the Telecommunications Act, the commission first asks whether conduct creates a preference or disadvantage. If it does, subsection 27(4) places the burden on the carrier to show that the difference is not undue or unreasonable.
The majority found a disadvantage because Fibernetics had to fund a new connection and wait for lower prices, or keep buying Rogers' transport. Rogers continued earning revenue during that period and also competed with Fibernetics in the retail Internet market.
But the majority found that Rogers consistently used the designated meeting point for third-party access. The existing fibre connection inside the building served unrelated services purchased for Rogers' own network, rather than constituting a second access point under the tariff.
The outdoor location was reasonably close, accessible and already equipped for interconnection and maintenance. The majority found no evidence that it was inefficient or that a more efficient location existed. An internal connection would require modifications and create equipment-access challenges.
The majority also considered that Fibernetics could recover the construction expense through the lower monthly transport prices. It relied on earlier decisions recognizing that carriers may take their network configuration, security and future plans into account when locating interconnection points, provided they comply with the Act.
Dissent focused on Rogers' advantage over competitors
Abramson accepted that Rogers did not have to operate its head-end as a carrier-neutral data centre. He nevertheless considered the majority's comparison incomplete: the relevant difference was between Rogers' own transport connection and the additional work required of Fibernetics' chosen provider.
In his view, complying with the Internet-access tariff did not answer whether the separate transport arrangement created an undue preference. Once the disadvantage was found, Rogers needed specific evidence showing why comparable access without new external construction was infeasible, unsafe or disproportionate.
Abramson found general references to network design and security insufficient. He also considered it circular to treat future savings from escaping higher prices as justification for the obstacle that delayed those savings.
He would have required negotiations within 60 days, with commission mediation available, followed by final-offer arbitration if needed. Possible solutions included a feasible connection without additional civil construction, fairly priced Rogers transport or another arrangement removing the competitive imbalance.
Broader allegations were left outside the ruling
The majority declined to impose a new industry-wide requirement to disclose exact connection locations under confidentiality agreements. Other affected providers had not received notice, and Rogers' tariff already offered a route to obtain location information.
It also left allegations of retaliatory pricing outside this dispute, explaining that affected customers could bring a separate application. Those allegations were not findings of misconduct.
The operative result was denial of the requested relief. Abramson's proposed negotiations and arbitration did not become commission orders.



