Tenants who rebuilt a deck without an agreement covering the expanded work recovered demolition labour, not the cost of the replacement, in a Newfoundland and Labrador tenancy ruling.

The May 21, 2026 decision 26-0101-NL distinguished optional improvements from necessary repairs. The landlord had agreed to replacement of old boards, but the tribunal found no agreement to pay for a complete rebuild. Permission or awareness of other improvements likewise did not establish a promise to reimburse.

Removing the unsafe existing deck was different. Taping it off did not satisfy the landlord’s maintenance obligation, and disclosure of its condition before move-in did not remove that duty. The tribunal awarded $576 for 24 hours of demolition labour.

The tenants also recovered $450 for a second rent increase that breached the Act. The first increase was upheld; the tribunal rejected the claim that it depended on installing insulation.

The total award was $1,026. The decision turns on the agreed scope of work, the safety repair and the separate legality of each rent increase.