
A Newfoundland and Labrador landlord established responsibility for shower damage but recovered only labour costs after failing to document the claimed materials and contractor charges.
In its May 21, 2026 decision 26-0323-NL, the Residential Tenancies Tribunal accepted that the tenant was responsible for deterioration after several months of sole use. It found negligence in failing to report the problem adequately, even if the tenant had not deliberately caused it.
The landlord sought $1,420 for restoring the shower. Without invoices, receipts or quotations, the tribunal instead allowed $192 for eight hours of cleaning and replacement labour at its self-labour rate.
A further $48 was awarded for two days of rent. The tenant had not finished vacating until the remaining belongings were removed and the keys returned.
The landlord’s timely deposit counterclaim was heard despite processing problems caused by technical errors, with both parties agreeing to proceed. After the $240 award was deducted from the deposit plus interest, the landlord had to return $139.80.



