The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission rejected Quebecor's request for a separate adjustment to Bell Canada's interim disaggregated fibre-access rates, prompting a dissent that accused the majority of leaving an outdated pricing regime in place while broader proceedings continued.

In Telecom Decision CRTC 2026-92, Quebecor Media Inc. – Application regarding the access rates for Bell Canada's disaggregated wholesale high-speed access services provided over its fibre-to-the-premises facilities, issued May 19, 2026, the majority decided that the rate issue belonged in its comprehensive wholesale Internet review.

Commissioner Bram Abramson disagreed. He would have addressed the substance of the application and moved the interim disaggregated rates closer to the aggregated rates approved in 2023, without waiting for a final decision on the broader framework.

Quebecor sought an interim correction

Quebecor applied in December 2023 on behalf of Videotron and VMedia. It asked the commission to bring Bell's interim rates for disaggregated fibre-to-the-premises access down to no more than the interim rates then established for the equivalent aggregated service.

The two models provide different forms of wholesale network access. In the disaggregated model, competitors connect at more points in the incumbent's network. Quebecor argued that the rate difference created a regulatory imbalance that hindered competitors offering retail Internet over fibre.

Execulink, the Public Interest Advocacy Centre and TekSavvy supported the request. They said the services relied on the same underlying access facilities and that the higher disaggregated rate reflected outdated cost assumptions. In their view, the aggregated rate offered a practical interim benchmark while the broader review proceeded.

Majority favoured one proceeding

Bell and Rogers opposed a separate ruling. Both said the future of disaggregated service and its rates were already within the review launched by Telecom Notice of Consultation 2023-56.

Bell argued that deciding Quebecor's application separately would duplicate that work and prejudge issues being considered on a fuller record. It also disputed whether aggregated rates could simply be used as a proxy, given differences in service configuration and cost structure.

Rogers said Quebecor had participated in the broader proceeding and could raise its concerns there. Parallel applications seeking overlapping relief, it argued, could waste resources and undermine procedural fairness.

The majority accepted the procedural approach. Because the comprehensive review covered both the future of disaggregated access and its associated rates, it considered a stand-alone adjustment premature and denied the application.

Dissent distinguished temporary prices from final policy

Abramson emphasized that the Telecommunications Act requires interim rates, as well as final rates, to be just and reasonable. Determining the long-term structure of a service did not remove the need to keep its temporary prices defensible, he wrote.

He pointed to rates filed and approved in 2017, nearly nine years before the decision. He described a 76 per cent premium for the disaggregated service and said differences in amortization and development-cost treatment had been corrected for aggregated access but not for disaggregated access.

The comparison did not require treating the services as identical, Abramson said. Even if full parity was inappropriate, the record supported some narrower interim correction. Continuing to apply deficient assumptions affected competitors' commercial decisions while the commission deliberated.

He also relied on subsection 61(2) of the Act, which allows final determinations to take effect from the date of an interim decision. In his analysis, a reversible adjustment could manage the risk of delay without deciding the ultimate framework in advance.

Aggregated rates were addressed separately

The May decision should be distinguished from Telecom Order CRTC 2026-77, issued April 24, which set final rates and terms for aggregated wholesale fibre access, subject to specified exceptions.

That earlier order expressly treated disaggregated pricing as a separate issue. It refused to include Bell's unrecovered disaggregated-service costs in aggregated fibre-access rates and said such costs belonged in the relevant service's own costing process.

The result in Quebecor's application was therefore a refusal to make the requested stand-alone disaggregated adjustment, not a ruling that all wholesale fibre rates were unchanged or that the commission had resolved the wider disaggregated-service review.

Source: Read the CRTC’s decision.