Lafleche could withhold a retracted paragraph of an auditor’s management letter because it contained advice, Saskatchewan’s information commissioner concluded.

In Review Report 205-2025, dated April 27, 2026, Commissioner Grace Hession David distinguished a management letter from the audit report available for public inspection under The Municipalities Act.

The town had released the audit report and revised letter. The applicant still wanted the original paragraph concerning a shop purchase. The auditor withdrew it after learning that council’s internal controls had been followed.

Inaccuracies are not themselves an exemption under The Local Authority Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. But section 16(1)(a) protected this paragraph: it interpreted facts and advised on possible legal consequences for council’s future consideration.

That the factual premise was later corrected did not erase its character as advice. The accounting firm had prepared it for the town, satisfying the second part of the test.

The commissioner recommended continued withholding of that paragraph only.