The Federal Court of Appeal upheld the foreign affairs minister’s refusal to recommend removing Katia and Laura Fridman from Canada’s Russia sanctions list, finding that the governing family-member provision did not require proof of the additional personal connections to Russia that they proposed.

In Fridman v. Canada (Foreign Affairs), 2026 FCA 80, released April 23, a unanimous panel dismissed both appeals. Justice K.A. Siobhan Monaghan concluded that the minister reasonably applied the legislation and explained how maintaining the listings served the sanctions regime’s objectives.

The ruling reviewed refusals to recommend delisting, not the original decisions to add the appellants’ names. It also was not a finding that either appellant had actually helped evade sanctions.

Family relationship was the listing basis

The appellants were listed on May 27, 2022 as family members of their father, Mikhail Maratovich Fridman. The reasons describe him as the founder and main shareholder of Alfa Group and explain that he had been listed the preceding month as an associate of Russian President Vladimir Putin.

Under the Special Economic Measures (Russia) Regulations, listing restricts specified activities by persons in Canada and Canadians abroad in relation to the listed person. A listed person may ask the minister to recommend removal to the Governor in Council.

The minister declined to recommend removal in both cases. The Federal Court dismissed the appellants’ judicial-review applications in a single set of reasons in 2025. On appeal, the parties agreed that reasonableness governed review; their dispute concerned whether the minister’s decisions met that standard.

No additional complicity requirement

The appellants argued that the family-member provision should be limited to people with a sufficiently strong connection to the foreign state’s actions. They said family ties alone were insufficient without something more, such as support for the Russian regime, assistance or willingness to assist their father in evading sanctions, or another meaningful connection indicating complicity.

The court rejected that proposed limitation. Paragraph 2(d) of the regulations did not contain the additional criteria the appellants sought to read into it. Other listing provisions expressly used limiting criteria, while the family-member provision did not.

The appellants also argued that the Special Economic Measures Act authorized measures only in relation to a foreign state. Although they did not challenge the regulations as a whole, they said their own inclusion exceeded that authority. They acknowledged that the original listings were not the decisions under review.

The court accepted that the legislation required some connection, but not one as substantial as they proposed. Reading the Act’s purpose and broad connecting language together, it found the minister’s rejection of that argument reasonable: the appellants were persons outside Canada who were not Canadian and were family members of a listed associate.

Reasons addressed their submissions

The appellants relied on their financial independence, opposition to the war in Ukraine, their father’s stated intention to give his fortune to charity and the asserted lack of connection between their listing and the sanctions objectives. They did not argue that the minister had overlooked their submissions; they said the explanations did not justify refusing relief.

The minister linked the listings to preventing evasion, encouraging behavioural change, denouncing Russia’s breach of international security and applying pressure on its regime. Her reasons explained that limited financial dependence did not prevent their father from attempting to use them to circumvent sanctions. The appellants had acknowledged receiving support and gifts from him.

The court found those reasons responsive to the evidence, submissions and state interests involved. It agreed that reviewing courts should not be unduly deferential, but distinguished the narrower statutory discretion considered in the Emergencies Act litigation from the broad sanctions discretion before it.

The appeals were dismissed with a single fixed costs award of $5,000 for both appeals, an amount agreed by the parties. The decision establishes the result of these delisting challenges, not a blanket exemption of sanctions decisions from judicial scrutiny.