The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld a trade tribunal’s $5,000 compensation recommendation for deficiencies in a federal emergency-towing procurement, rejecting a losing bidder’s request to cancel the contract and recover for a lost opportunity.

In Heiltsuk Horizon Maritime Services Ltd. v. Atlantic Towing Limited, 2026 FCA 69, the court distinguished a failure to document the evaluation of replacement ship masters from a finding that those masters actually lacked the required qualifications. The April 2 judgment dismissed judicial review of the Canadian International Trade Tribunal’s remedies decision without an award of appeal-court costs.

Earlier challenge succeeded on the evidentiary record

Public Works awarded Atlantic Towing a contract in August 2018 to supply two emergency towing vessels supporting Canadian Coast Guard operations on Canada’s west coast. Heiltsuk Horizon Maritime Services and Horizon Maritime Services ranked last among seven compliant bidders.

Several weeks later, Public Works permitted Atlantic Towing to replace all four ship masters proposed in its winning bid. The solicitation allowed substitutions, but the applicants challenged whether the replacements met its technical requirements and whether allowing them effectively changed the procurement for Atlantic Towing alone.

The tribunal initially rejected the complaint. Although it criticized the lack of contemporaneous documentation, it accepted material supplied during the litigation as supporting the replacements’ qualifications and equivalent scores.

In 2023 FCA 88, the appeal court overturned that result. The tribunal could not supply a retrospective justification for Public Works’ decision when the contemporaneous evidence did not support the necessary conclusion. The court declared the complaint valid rather than sending the merits back for another decision.

Valid complaint did not establish a different procurement

On the resulting remedies proceeding, the tribunal characterized the breach as insufficient rigour in validating and documenting the replacement masters’ experience. It recommended $5,000 compensation, verification and documentation of the masters’ qualifications at the next potential contract extension, and reimbursement of reasonable complaint costs.

The applicants argued that this understated the breach. They sought contract cancellation and compensation for lost opportunity, maintaining that Public Works had effectively conducted a new, sole-source procurement.

The appeal court found that argument depended on a factual premise the earlier proceedings had not established: that the replacement masters failed to meet the requirements or could not achieve the original masters’ scores. The earlier judgment concerned an evidentiary gap, not a finding of deficient qualifications.

The tribunal’s earlier observation that allowing lower scores would effectively create a different evaluation process was conditional. It had not found that lower scores were actually permitted.

Contract stage and bidder ranking mattered

Reviewing the remedy for reasonableness, the court found the tribunal had considered the relevant statutory factors and procurement circumstances. Cancelling a contract already well into performance raised concerns about interrupting an essential service. Compensation for a lost opportunity was inappropriate given the applicants’ last-place ranking among compliant bidders.

The $5,000 recommendation addressed the procurement-integrity shortcoming without treating it as proof that the applicants should have received the contract. The court found that recommendation reasonable in the circumstances.

The dismissal left the tribunal’s remedies decision in place. It did not erase the applicants’ earlier successful complaint, and the absence of costs in this judicial review is distinct from the tribunal’s award of reasonable complaint costs.