The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld the refusal of a broad transaction-data production request in the Competition Commissioner’s investigation into allegedly purchased product reviews on Amazon’s Canadian platform.

In Canada (Commissioner of Competition) v. Amazon.com.ca, ULC, 2026 FCA 64, the court found that the commissioner had not sufficiently explained the request’s scope for a judge to assess whether the proposed intrusion was justified. The March 27 judgment dismissed the commissioner’s appeal with costs. The official reasons carry a June 19 correction notice.

The decision concerns investigative powers, not whether Amazon engaged in deceptive marketing. The commissioner was investigating whether the respondents permitted reviews purchased by vendors to remain online; the reasons describe that possible conduct as an allegation requiring proof.

Uncertainty about the proposed order

The request sought transaction data across health and personal care, home and kitchen, tools and home improvement, and electronics products sold in Canada through the platform.

The Federal Court approved two other schedules of the proposed production order but declined to approve this one. It adjourned the hearing and encouraged the commissioner to clarify the request with the respondents, whose lawyers had raised breadth concerns. The commissioner instead filed additional affidavit evidence without further discussions.

At the second hearing, the judge remained uncertain about the volume of products and records captured. The appeal court concluded that the refusal rested on that lack of information, not on accepting the respondents’ untested assertions about the number of products.

Relevance does not remove judicial discretion

Section 11 of the Competition Act allows a judge to order production when an inquiry is underway and the target has, or likely has, relevant information. Satisfying those conditions does not make an order automatic. The judge retains discretion that must respect Charter protection against unreasonable search or seizure.

Business records attract a reduced expectation of privacy, and regulatory production orders are less intrusive than physical searches. Nevertheless, privacy interests remain. Judges must assess whether requested information exceeds what is reasonably required for the inquiry or unjustifiably intrudes on those interests.

The commissioner argued that earlier Federal Court decisions had improperly imported civil-discovery proportionality into an investigation. The appeal court agreed that the two processes serve different purposes and cannot simply share the same rules. But read in context, the judge’s reasons applied the investigative and constitutional framework rather than demanding relevance to a pleaded trial case.

Cost and effort are not the same as privacy

The court qualified the earlier case law in an important respect. It said the suggestion that production should be limited to what a target can supply through reasonable effort or cost went too far. The Charter inquiry concerns privacy, not economic interests or the difficulty of complying.

That did not change the result here. The decisive problem was uncertainty about the request’s scope and whether it exceeded what the investigation reasonably required. A judge could not perform the necessary balancing without understanding what the state sought to obtain.

Safeguards apply before an order is made

The respondents’ letters were properly before the court through the commissioner’s duty of full, fair and frank disclosure in an application heard without the other side participating. They informed the judge about the parties’ discussions and concerns; the judge did not treat their contents as proven facts.

The court also rejected the commissioner’s proposed two-stage model under which concerns could await a later motion to vary or set aside the order. That remedy does not relieve the issuing judge of responsibility for scrutiny before authorizing production.

The result leaves the particular data request refused while preserving both the commissioner’s investigative mandate and the judge’s obligation to assess a properly explained request.