Albertans who filled out the Alberta Next panel’s surveys disagreed about pensions, immigration and policing. Those answers showed what residents wanted the province to do. They gave no indication which course the government had chosen, adjudicator Teresa Cunningham found in five access orders issued on February 5, 2026.

Executive Council and Communications and Public Engagement had relied on section 29(1)(g) of Alberta’s Access to Information Act to withhold the responses. The provision allows a public body to protect information that could reasonably be expected to reveal a pending policy or budgetary decision. The dispute turned on what counts as a pending decision.

Officials said the panel had sought public input across six topics to develop recommendations. The feedback could also help shape questions for a possible provincial referendum in 2026. Releasing early responses while the portal was open, they argued, risked influencing later participants and skewing the feedback on which the panel would rely. After the surveys closed on October 31, 2025, and the panel delivered its recommendations, officials offered to reconsider the requests.

The applicant pointed out that the government had published statistical summaries in December. In four of the inquiries, the applicant argued that officials were trying to control when results came out and that an administrative policy on preliminary results could not create a new exception to the Act.

Cunningham examined the records themselves. The respondents held conflicting views and did not know what the government would decide. Officials identified neither a particular decision that the answers would reveal nor evidence connecting any individual response to such a decision. A decision is pending in this context, she explained, once the government has made it but has yet to announce or implement it.

An earlier case illustrated the distinction. There, records about the scope and resources for developing regulations revealed a policy choice already made. Another case involved telephone surveys about employment standards. Those answers could support several different policy changes, leaving a reader unable to tell which, if any, the government had chosen. Cunningham found the Alberta Next responses fell on the survey side of that line even while consultations were open.

Three orders concerned Executive Council records from June 24 and 25, 2025. Order ATIA2026-03 dealt with 213 pages from the panel’s general contact form, subject to the applicant’s limit on fees and exclusions for personal, business and privileged information. Order ATIA2026-04 covered 132 pages involving pension questions 5 and 7. Executive Council had also removed material outside the request. Order ATIA2026-05 concerned 223 pages involving immigration question 6.

Two requests to Communications and Public Engagement specified questions that gave respondents an “other” option. Order ATIA2026-06 covered July 16 to 18 responses about the benefits and risks of replacing the RCMP with a provincial police service. Order ATIA2026-07 covered the benefits and risks of leaving the Canada Pension Plan. In that file, Cunningham had the government’s submission and the applicant’s arguments from the four related inquiries and decided she could rule without further submissions.

Each public body had to give the applicant access to the information it had withheld under section 29(1)(g) and confirm compliance in writing within 50 business days of receiving the order. The inquiries resolved the policy exemption. Separate privacy grounds cited in some responses were outside their scope.