The Supreme Court of Canada restored an Ontario accident-benefits claimant’s opportunity to challenge a tribunal ruling that her claim was too late, rejecting the view that judicial review should be confined to rare cases when legislation allows appeals only on questions of law.

In Yatar v. TD Insurance Meloche Monnex, 2024 SCC 8, the unanimous court held that the limited appeal route did not prevent judicial review of questions of fact or mixed fact and law. It also found the Licence Appeal Tribunal’s reconsideration decision unreasonable because the adjudicator had overlooked the possible effect of reinstated benefits on the limitation period.

Justice Malcolm Rowe, writing for all nine judges on March 15, 2024, sent the matter back to the adjudicator. The court did not decide that Ummugulsum Yatar was entitled to the disputed benefits or finally determine whether her claim was timely.

A benefits claim stopped at the deadline

Yatar was injured in a February 2010 automobile accident. TD Insurance initially paid benefits, but its subsequent correspondence treated different benefits differently.

A January 2011 letter stopped income replacement, housekeeping and home maintenance payments because a completed disability certificate had not been supplied. The letter included a dispute resolution form. After medical assessments, a February letter reinstated income replacement benefits while denying housekeeping and home maintenance benefits. A September letter then denied further income replacement payments. Neither later letter included a dispute resolution form.

Under the legislation governing the dispute at the time, an insured person generally had two years after an insurer’s refusal to pay to commence proceedings. Mandatory mediation could extend that period. Yatar applied for mediation in September 2012; the mediator’s report was issued in January 2014.

She later brought a Superior Court action that was dismissed by consent, and applied to the tribunal in March 2018. By then, legislative changes had transferred these disputes to the tribunal and eliminated mandatory mediation.

The adjudicator dismissed her application in 2019 and upheld that result on reconsideration. He treated the January 2011 letter as a valid denial and concluded the extended limitation period had expired in April 2014.

Yatar pursued both an appeal on questions of law and judicial review of factual and mixed questions. The Divisional Court dismissed both. The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the result, treating judicial review as a remedy to be exercised only rarely in this statutory scheme. It also concluded that the tribunal’s decision was reasonable even if review should have proceeded.

A narrow appeal does not close the review route

Yatar argued that an appeal restricted to legal questions could not adequately address her complaints about factual or mixed findings. TD Insurance defended the lower courts’ discretion and argued that Ontario had chosen to limit court involvement and streamline accident-benefits disputes. The tribunal likewise supported the rare-cases approach, while taking no position on whether its own decision was reasonable.

The Supreme Court rejected the inference that a limited appeal signalled legislative intent to restrict judicial review of other questions. Providing an appeal on questions of law meant those questions would be reviewed for correctness. Questions of fact or mixed fact and law could instead be examined on judicial review under the more deferential reasonableness standard.

That distinction respected the legislature’s design. Judicial review did not turn the restricted appeal into an unrestricted opportunity to have a court decide every issue afresh.

Nor did the judgment make a hearing on the merits or a remedy automatic. A judge must at least consider whether judicial review is appropriate. Recognized discretionary grounds—such as undue delay, misconduct or an adequate alternative remedy—can justify declining to examine the merits. A court can also withhold relief after finding a decision unreasonable.

The assessment must consider both available alternatives and whether judicial review is suitable in the circumstances. Here, neither suggested alternative was adequate. The statutory appeal could not address factual and mixed questions, and internal reconsideration had already occurred: the reconsideration decision was itself being challenged.

Streamlining proceedings and reducing costs were legitimate concerns, the court held, but had to be weighed against a meaningful means of challenging unreasonable or procedurally unfair administrative decisions. The court expressly left for another case the effect of clauses that seek to bar or restrict judicial review.

Reinstated payments required a fresh look

The court separately examined the tribunal’s reasoning, rather than stopping after correcting the lower courts’ approach to review.

The adjudicator had relied on the January denial, the accompanying notice of dispute procedures and the mediation history. But he had not considered what happened when TD reinstated income replacement benefits between February and September 2011.

He also failed to consider earlier tribunal decisions indicating that, after reinstatement, a limitation period could begin only when benefits were validly terminated again. Yatar argued that the later letters were not valid denials because they lacked dispute resolution forms; the adjudicator had also reached that conclusion about those letters.

The mediation provisions were another important distinction. They extended an existing two-year limitation period; they did not independently create a 90-day limitation period running from the mediator’s report. It remained arguable that a valid denial was needed to start the clock in the first place.

The Supreme Court deliberately left that question to the tribunal. Its order required the adjudicator to reconsider how reinstatement affected the validity of the initial denial and the resulting limitation period. TD Insurance was ordered to pay Yatar’s costs in the Supreme Court and the courts below. The judgment did not award accident benefits.

What happened after the remittal

On October 21, 2024, the tribunal issued its decision after the Supreme Court’s remittal. It allowed Yatar’s income replacement claim to proceed, finding that reinstatement had ended the limitation period triggered by the initial denial. The September letter did not start a new period because it lacked a dispute resolution form. Her housekeeping and home maintenance claim remained time-barred: those benefits had never been reinstated, and the January letter was a valid denial. This preliminary ruling did not award benefits or decide the income replacement claim on its merits.

Source: Supreme Court of Canada, 2024 SCC 8.