
PEI court dismisses third-party claim in BMO debt action
The ruling removes a pleading against 27 entities but leaves the bank’s claim and LaCroix’s counterclaim undecided.
Section
Civil lawsuits and court proceedings across Canada, including liability, damages, contracts, property and estate disputes, class actions, settlements and enforcement.
417 stories
The ruling removes a pleading against 27 entities but leaves the bank’s claim and LaCroix’s counterclaim undecided.


Appeal court distinguishes forfeiting a true deposit from recovering the same damages twice after buyers wrongfully refuse to close.

The court reversed Gowling’s disqualification from Piikani Nation litigation, distinguishing a company’s legal rights from those of its former executive.

Federation of Newfoundland Indians cannot use its response to broaden the appeal into new claims and collective remedies.

A proposed lift pump was not an equivalent remedy, the court found; the damages assessment separates the builders’ liability from a settling subcontractor’s share.

Replacement request failed on the document’s wording.

The decision enforces a negotiated resignation agreement without deciding the merits of the employee’s dispute with her school district.

Manitoba judge rejected shareholder meetings with defective notices and confirmed a five-member board that still included Benjamin Nasberg.

A Manitoba homeowner’s claim failed because he accepted an interruption lasting more than a year, even though he continued driving over part of the disputed strip.

Access protects the client’s interests, but does not open the files to opposing parties.

A Manitoba judge awarded both paid and unpaid deposits plus damages, while rejecting the buyer’s misrepresentation counterclaim and preserving its separate claims against realtors.

Minty’s Moving can pursue contract rights, but paying money into court did not entitle it to a custom box under the garage-lien statute.

The customer has sought Supreme Court review after losing challenges to arbitration and the pleaded misleading-advertising claim.


A non-exclusive jurisdiction clause carried only moderate weight against the employee’s local work and access-to-justice concerns.

The 6–3 result preserves a $100,000 award while changing its legal basis, with separate opinions divided over the new tort’s scope and necessity.

The Federal Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal but criticized missing findings about the clarity and enforceability of the California forum clauses.

The judge found neither admissible nor credible evidence requiring a trial and ordered substantial-indemnity costs, with the amount left open.

Detailed evidence of two businesses’ dependence on loading docks supported temporary protection, while competing lease interpretations remained for trial.