
The Federal Court has upheld an immigration ruling that a truck driver was inadmissible to Canada after border officers found a product containing opium in his bag. The judge rejected challenges to both the finding that he knew what he possessed and the evidence linking the seized material to laboratory testing.
In Sidhu v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2026 FC 1395, Justice Julie Blackhawk dismissed Gurmukh S. Sidhu’s application for judicial review. The November 13 decision left the Immigration Division’s transborder-criminality finding in place. It was an immigration proceeding, not a criminal conviction, and the reasons do not establish that Sidhu has been removed from Canada.
A border search led to an admissibility hearing
Sidhu, an Indian citizen working as a transport truck driver, sought entry at the Lansdowne, Ontario border crossing in September 2024 with a co-driver. They were driving a commercial truck toward Quebec when officers referred them for secondary examination.
Officers found bottles of Kamini in separate bags that the two men identified as their own. Pills were also found in the co-driver’s pocket. The seized product was sent for analysis, and an October 2024 laboratory report identified opium in the material attributed to Sidhu.
Following an interview with a minister’s delegate, assisted by a Punjabi interpreter, and a later joint admissibility hearing, the Immigration Division found Sidhu inadmissible in May 2025. He challenged that decision, arguing that knowing possession at the time of entry had not been established and that the evidence did not reliably identify which pills had been tested.
The applicable immigration standard was reasonable grounds to believe: more than suspicion, but less than proof on a balance of probabilities. Blackhawk emphasized that judicial review concerned whether the division’s decision was reasonable, rather than whether guilt had been proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
The interview supported the finding of knowledge
Sidhu argued that the delegate’s repeated use of the word opium could have taught him what the product contained during the interview. The relevant question, he said, was what he knew before crossing the border. He also suggested that translation difficulties could explain his responses.
The court found that the interview, viewed as a whole, reasonably supported the division’s conclusion. When asked about opium use, Sidhu answered without clarifying that he meant only Kamini, which he later characterized as a natural health product. He also used the word opium in describing his own consumption.
Later, he denied knowing that the tablets contained opium. The delegate put the inconsistency to him. Sidhu responded that the product was prescribed by a doctor, but did not explain the contradiction after the delegate pointed out that the bottle was not a prescription bottle.
Blackhawk held that questioning designed to gather information and elicit admissions was a legitimate investigative technique. The division could reasonably reject the later denial and find reasonable grounds to believe Sidhu knew the product contained a controlled substance when he entered Canada.
Translation concerns lacked a timely evidentiary foundation
The translation argument failed for separate reasons. The court was not persuaded that Sidhu had clearly raised the alleged problem with the Immigration Division. His statement there that he took the medicine for back pain did not adequately identify a concern about the interpreter’s use of the word opium.
Sidhu had not testified about mistranslation before the division, supplied an affidavit identifying specific errors, or provided evidence about potentially interchangeable Punjabi terminology. Blackhawk found the record insufficient to assess the allegation and noted that interpretation concerns must be raised at the earliest opportunity.
The court also rejected the suggestion that the interview interpreter had to provide the same oath or affirmation required for an Immigration Division hearing. Sidhu had identified no authority supporting that requirement in the delegate’s interview. The allegation therefore did not make reliance on the interview notes unreasonable.
Records connected the seized product to the laboratory
Sidhu separately relied on a passage in the division’s reasons expressing uncertainty about whether the tested pills came from pockets or bags. The court agreed that the reasons could have been more precise, but found the full documentary record answered the concern.
The seizure report, a receipt signed by Sidhu, the chain-of-custody records and the laboratory report consistently tracked the same seizure reference. Those records connected the material identified as his to the package received and tested by the laboratory. The court found that the division had considered the alleged irregularities and reasonably accepted the chain of custody.
Similar wording in officers’ declarations did not, by itself, establish a problem with the investigation. The division had noted that the accuracy of those declarations had not been challenged on that basis.
There was one factual mistake: the division said Sidhu had pills in his pocket, when that was true of the co-driver. Blackhawk treated it as a minor error because Sidhu acknowledged ownership of the bag containing Kamini, and the records independently linked that seized material to the opium finding.
The application was dismissed, with no question certified for appeal. The ruling did not determine any separate criminal charge or document a later enforcement outcome.
Source: Sidhu v. Canada (Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness), 2026 FC 1395.



