
The Federal Court has ordered the immigration minister to decide a permanent residence application within 90 days after it remained unresolved for more than three years. Security screening had finished by the hearing, but no final decision followed before judgment. Chief Justice Alan Diner found that the unexplained delay justified an order compelling a decision.
The November 12 ruling in Belenikin v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1381, concerns an application through the New Brunswick Provincial Nominee Program. It requires a final determination, not approval of permanent residence. The judge also declined to certify a proposed appeal question about legal costs after the applicant withdrew his request for them.
Screening ended, but the application remained open
Pavel Belenikin, a Russian citizen, received his provincial nomination on September 25, 2023, and applied to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada on October 2. IRCC sought biometric fees and later requested records concerning his military service, employment and family. He supplied the requested material within the deadlines in spring 2024. Security screening began on May 30 that year.
Belenikin pursued updates through webforms, phone calls and his member of Parliament. File notes from May 2025 showed that eligibility and criminality assessments had passed and information sharing was complete. His medical assessment had passed but expired. IRCC requested further details about vehicles he could operate or repair during his military service in September 2026.
At the October 22 hearing, the government said security screening had been completed on or shortly before that date. It did not disclose the result to the court. The permanent residence application remained undecided when Diner issued judgment.
Belenikin said the uncertainty prevented major decisions about his family’s future and affected his health. The minister argued that the requirements for mandamus, the court order he sought, had not been met.
Why the court ordered a decision
Diner applied the eight-part mandamus test recently restated by the Federal Court of Appeal in Benison. Its first four requirements address entitlement to an order, including a public duty owed to the applicant, a clear right to its performance and the rules governing discretionary duties. The remaining requirements concern reasons a court might nevertheless refuse relief: an adequate alternative remedy, lack of practical value, an equitable barrier or the balance of convenience.
All eight requirements must favour the applicant. Diner found that Belenikin established the first four and that the minister had not shown why any of the remaining four defeated his application.
The judge accepted the importance of security investigations and the minister’s responsibility to protect Canada and the integrity of immigration decisions. The problem was the lengthy processing delay without an explanation. In those circumstances, the balance of convenience favoured Belenikin.
The remedy’s timing was settled after further discussion. Belenikin asked the court to retain supervision of the case, but Diner declined. The parties agreed to 90 days rather than the 60 initially contemplated, allowing any additional procedural steps, such as a fairness letter, to be taken early enough for a final decision. Government counsel noted that Belenikin could seek judicial review if dissatisfied with that decision.
A costs question left unresolved
Belenikin initially sought solicitor-client costs without specifying an amount. The minister opposed costs regardless of the result. Diner noted a longstanding division in decisions awarding costs in immigration mandamus cases, an issue made more prominent by their growing numbers. According to the reasons, mandamus applications accounted for almost a quarter of immigration judicial reviews filed in the Federal Court in 2025.
Before a November 9 case-management conference, Diner proposed certifying a question about whether an unreasonable IRCC delay could constitute a special reason for awarding costs under the immigration court rules.
Belenikin’s counsel opposed certification and said his client would no longer seek costs. The minister also opposed certification. Persuaded that certification was inappropriate in light of the parties’ positions, Diner certified no question and awarded no costs. The judgment therefore left the broader costs issue unresolved while imposing the 90-day deadline in Belenikin’s case.



