An Ontario developer that paid its general contractor’s subcontractors directly has lost its bid to restore a $3.55-million reduction in lien security. In Demikon Construction Ltd. v. Oakleigh Holdings Inc., the Court of Appeal for Ontario held that the developer had to show which subcontractors still had liens when it paid them and how much of each payment qualified. Its records did not establish either point with enough precision.

Aurelia Limited Partnership hired Demikon Construction Ltd. as general contractor and construction manager for the Matchedash Lofts condominium project in Orillia. Citing delays and deficiencies, Aurelia terminated the contract in March 2021. Two days later, Demikon registered a lien for just over $5 million in unpaid invoices. Aurelia posted about $5.09 million in security to remove the lien from the property’s title while the claim proceeded.

Aurelia and its general partner, Oakleigh Holdings Inc., sought credit for payments made directly to Demikon’s subcontractors and suppliers. They said the accounts they had paid were already included in Demikon’s lien. A motion judge reduced the security by $3,554,224.83. The Divisional Court reversed that order, and the companies appealed.

When a direct payment counts

Under section 28 of the former Construction Lien Act, an owner can pay a subcontractor directly even though the contractor ordinarily owes the bill. If the owner pays a person who has a lien and gives the proper payer written notice of the payment or the intention to pay, the statute treats the qualifying payment as one made to the proper payer. The payment does not reduce the statutory holdback or the amount the payer must retain in response to another person’s written notice of lien. The court said its interpretation also applies to the current Construction Act because the relevant provisions are unchanged.

Aurelia argued that a subcontractor qualified if money was owing for work or materials supplied to the project. Writing for the unanimous panel, Justice Osborne said that reading overlooked the statutory requirement that the recipient have a lien. A subcontractor can qualify before registering a lien, but a payment to someone whose lien has expired or been resolved falls outside the provision. Section 44(5) gives a judge discretion to reduce security. It does not independently give an owner credit for paying a subcontractor.

What the records could not establish

The record did not show when each subcontractor last supplied labour or materials. Some payments came more than a year after Aurelia terminated Demikon’s contract. Nor could the panel separate work performed for Demikon from work performed directly for Aurelia, or reliably match negotiated discounts to particular invoices.

The motion judge had found that the lien was over-secured. Even so, the panel needed evidence from which it could calculate the reduction, and the party asking for it bore the burden of proving the amount. The panel dismissed the appeal but left the companies free to bring a fresh motion with better evidence. It awarded $30,000 in appeal costs, including disbursements and HST, and left the Divisional Court’s costs award in place.

Read the Court of Appeal’s decision, 2026 ONCA 808.