
A Manitoba judge has refused to order Wynward Insurance Group to share a contractor’s defence costs in a condominium-defect lawsuit, finding that the pleaded ownership of the property engaged a policy exclusion. The ruling applies only to the first stage of the insurance dispute and leaves the ultimate coverage question open.
In Federated Insurance Company of Canada et al. v. Wynward Insurance Group, 2026 MBKB 154, Justice Toews dismissed the interim duty-to-defend application brought by Federated and Hillside Construction Inc. The November 3 decision expressly allows for a different conclusion at the second stage on a fuller evidentiary record, after the underlying condominium action ends.
Hillside built a three-building condominium project in Manitoba in 2012–2013. Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No. 811 later sued it over alleged construction deficiencies, including water infiltration, rotting wood and sheathing, and mould. Those allegations have not been decided by this ruling.
A proposed split between successive insurers
Federated and Hillside argued that successive commercial general liability policies placed both Federated and Wynward on risk. They said the alleged damage was latent, developed over time and became apparent in 2019, making it impossible to settle the insurers’ respective responsibility at this stage.
They proposed a continuous approach to coverage, treating damage as occurring from exposure to the conditions that caused it through its eventual discovery. On that theory, they argued, Wynward insured much of the relevant period. They asked for an equal allocation of defence expenses already incurred and still to come, subject to later adjustment when the condominium litigation was resolved.
The applicants also relied on the possibility that accidental construction defects could constitute an insured occurrence and that the alleged deterioration could qualify as property damage. In their view, the allegations were enough to trigger Wynward’s duty to defend.
Wynward disputed coverage. It said the project had been expressly excluded during negotiations, relied on the policy’s Damage to Property exclusion, and alleged that Hillside had failed to provide timely notice and had prejudiced its position. Alternatively, it argued for no more than a 10 per cent share of reasonable defence costs from the time it received notice, subject to policy limits and deductibles.
The judge did not resolve that allocation dispute or all the competing coverage arguments. The exclusion and the evidence permissible at this preliminary stage were decisive.
The pleadings, not a factual trial, controlled
Justice Toews held that even if the applicants had shown a mere possibility that the condominium claim fell within the insuring agreement, the claim clearly and unambiguously fell within an exclusion on the record properly before the court.
The court applied the pleadings rule. For this duty-to-defend analysis, it had to accept the allegations in the underlying claim as true, rather than determine what had actually happened. That approach keeps the preliminary obligation to defend distinct from the later question of whether the insurer must indemnify the insured for a loss.
The applicants sought to rely on additional affidavit evidence. The judge excluded it for two separate reasons. First, the affidavits were filed outside the timetable the parties had agreed upon. Second, the material was not permissible evidence for determining the substance and true nature of the allegations at this stage.
On that second ground, the proposed evidence would have drawn the court into factual findings and mixed the duty-to-defend inquiry with the indemnity inquiry. Its exclusion therefore rested on more than the filing delay.
The relevant pleadings said that Hillside owned, developed and constructed the project using contractors and subcontractors. The judge also noted Hillside’s admission that it owned the property throughout construction. Taken as true for this analysis, those matters engaged the Damage to Property exclusion.
Final coverage and costs remain open
The reasons do not reproduce the exclusion’s wording. The ruling turns on its application to the pleaded ownership and construction allegations, rather than a finding that every construction-defect claim falls outside commercial liability insurance.
Justice Toews declined to decide Wynward’s broader position that coverage could never exist for the claim. The judge also cautioned that the exclusion itself could produce a different result when considered with all the evidence at the second stage.
No half-share payment was ordered, and the alternative 10 per cent allocation was not adopted. The applicants’ first-stage duty-to-defend relief was dismissed. Costs for that stage may be addressed at the second stage, following the conclusion of the condominium action.
Source: Federated Insurance Company of Canada et al. v. Wynward Insurance Group, 2026 MBKB 154.



