
A tenant’s dispute about pigeon waste outside his window did not have a reasonable prospect of becoming an age-discrimination case, the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has ruled.
The decision is Burton v. Chen, 2026 BCHRT 237, published by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal.
Vice-chair Devyn Cousineau dismissed Robert Burton’s complaint against landlord Scott Chen under section 27(1)(c) of the Human Rights Code. The November 6 decision did not determine who was responsible for cleaning the ledge or resolve the parties’ competing accounts of their tenancy dispute.
Burton, who was 74 at the relevant time, said he was physically unable to remove the pigeon faeces himself. He had withheld rent over the problem and was evicted in 2021 for non-payment, a result upheld by the Residential Tenancy Branch. The dispute also generated other proceedings.
Chen denied discrimination. He said he had arranged twice for a cleaning company to attend, but Burton refused access. At this preliminary stage, the tribunal did not make findings about those disputed facts.
The missing connection was between age and the alleged harm. Cousineau considered the complaint on the assumption that Burton could establish adverse effects from the tenancy problems, despite the parties’ disagreement and findings in the tenancy proceedings. That still left him needing evidence that age was a factor.
Burton did not explain how his age connected to rent, eviction, the alleged building-code problems or susceptibility to the claimed health hazard. His central argument was that his age prevented him from cleaning the outside ledge.
But there was no evidence that Chen expected or required Burton personally to do the cleaning. Even if Chen regarded cleaning as the tenant’s responsibility, that did not establish a requirement to carry it out without help. Burton had hired a company, and the tenancy branch had ordered reimbursement, although not as much as he sought.
The ruling distinguishes a potentially costly or unhealthy housing dispute from discrimination on a protected ground. It does not decide that the underlying conditions were acceptable, or that an older tenant can never need accommodation. On this record, the necessary link between age and the claimed tenancy harm had no reasonable prospect of being established.
Having dismissed the complaint on that basis, the tribunal did not need to decide the landlord’s alternative argument that another proceeding had already dealt appropriately with its substance.
The respondent bore the burden on the dismissal application. The threshold for a hearing was low: the complainant did not have to prove the case at this stage, but the evidence had to move the alleged discrimination beyond conjecture.



