
Rogami Services Limited has lost its challenge to a labour-market assessment refusal for two personal care aide jobs, after the Federal Court found it reasonable to conclude that the offers did not meet the regulatory genuineness requirement.
In Rogami Services Limited v. Canada (Employment and Social Development), 2026 FC 1367, decided November 6, 2026, Justice François Joyal dismissed the staffing agency’s judicial-review application. The ruling turned on the relationship between the proposed jobs, the agency’s own business and its ability to control the promised working conditions.
Two positions, but whose employment needs?
Rogami applied on April 17, 2024 for a Labour Market Impact Assessment covering two full-time personal care aide positions in Kingston, Ontario. An Employment and Social Development Canada officer refused the application on August 1, 2024.
The officer gave two grounds: the job offers were not genuine under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations, and the proposed employment was unlikely to have a neutral or positive effect on the Canadian labour market.
A positive assessment is generally required before a foreign national can obtain a work permit under this route, unless an exemption applies. The program is intended to address immediate labour or skill shortages when qualified Canadians and permanent residents are unavailable.
Staffing services were not direct personal care
The court reviewed the refusal for reasonableness. It asked whether the reasons formed a coherent analysis justified by the record and governing law, rather than deciding the application afresh.
The genuineness assessment considers whether the employer is actively engaged in the business connected to the offer, whether the offer matches its reasonable employment needs, whether it can fulfil the terms, and its past compliance with employment and recruitment laws. The officer relied on the first three factors here.
Rogami’s website and application described a healthcare staffing agency. The officer found that it did not operate a care institution or directly provide personal care services. Its business was placing workers with clients. On that record, the court held, the officer could reasonably conclude that the jobs met the clients’ labour needs rather than the agency’s own needs.
The agency could meet the offers’ financial obligations. But the officer found that other terms, including working conditions, depended on the client facilities.
Missing contracts mattered
Rogami maintained that its agreements with clients protected the offered terms and that it controlled workers’ hours and conditions. When the officer requested those contracts, however, its representative declined to provide them on the ground that the request was outside the application’s scope.
The agency also could not identify which retirement homes would receive the workers because placement would depend on demand. The court found that those gaps supported the conclusion that Rogami had not demonstrated its ability to fulfil the offers.
The court rejected the claimed contradictions in the officer’s notes. A description of a healthcare agency supplying staff reflected Rogami’s own account, not a contrary finding that it directly provided care. Similarly, the occupational code for nurse aides described the offered positions, not the agency’s business.
A positive assessment obtained in October 2023 did not establish unreasonable inconsistency. That earlier decision had no reasons before the court, its underlying materials were unavailable, and it involved a different stream, work location and wage.
Separate labour-market finding left undecided
Because the genuineness finding was sufficient to dispose of the application, the judge did not decide whether the officer’s separate conclusion about efforts to hire Canadians or permanent residents was reasonable.
The court also rejected the procedural-fairness complaint. The brief refusal letter had to be read with the assessment and interview notes, which explained the concerns. Rogami had been told of those concerns in writing and by telephone and had an opportunity to respond.
The judgment corrected the parties’ names to identify the company, rather than its general manager, as applicant and the responsible employment minister as respondent. It dismissed judicial review and certified no question for appeal. The decision addresses this record; it does not announce that every staffing agency is barred from obtaining an assessment.



