
Concerns about an unfair hiring process did not give a Vernon bylaw officer’s age-discrimination complaint a reasonable prospect of success, the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has ruled.
The decision is Knipstrom v. The City of Vernon, 2026 BCHRT 226, issued by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal on 2026-10-30.
Holly Knipstrom was offered a temporary full-time position in late 2021 but declined it for personal reasons. About two months later, when she was 60, a younger colleague won a similar permanent position. Knipstrom argued that the changed result, interview criticism and advance help given to other candidates supported an inference of ageism.
Tribunal member Carol Whittome dismissed the complaint under section 27(1)(c) of the Human Rights Code. She made no final findings on disputed facts and did not certify the hiring process as fair. The City bore the burden of establishing dismissal. Her question was whether the evidence could connect the alleged unfairness to age.
The City said the successful candidate gave stronger interview answers. Knipstrom argued that her superior qualifications and earlier success made the reversal inexplicable. But the collective-agreement process used qualifications as an entry threshold, with the competition then determined through interview and assessment performance. The earlier praise did not require the same outcome in the later competition.
Knipstrom also relied on a manager’s note criticizing her use of paper planning tools rather than technology. Whittome accepted that such a comment could reflect age stereotypes in another context. Here, however, it recorded Knipstrom’s own description of using a paper calendar and notebook, rather than an assumption about what older workers could do. Disagreement with the manager’s view of efficiency was not evidence of age bias.
There was evidence that a senior officer had advised two other candidates to prepare for a soil-deposition question. Whittome acknowledged that giving only some candidates advance information raises fairness concerns. But there was no evidence connecting the help, or the manager’s communication with the senior officer, to the candidates’ ages. The record instead showed an already poor working relationship between Knipstrom and the senior officer.
Potential disputes about who shared the information did not require a hearing because they did not address the missing link to age. The tribunal had to assess the evidence filed, not anticipate testimony that might emerge later.
Statistics showing no permanent full-time bylaw hires over 60 in 2021 also fell short. The record did not establish the ages of applicants or even whether people over 60 had applied for those positions. Without that denominator, the hiring outcomes could not support the proposed inference.
Whittome considered the evidence both separately and together. A younger candidate’s selection, even alongside potentially legitimate fairness concerns, did not establish a reasonable prospect of proving age was a factor. Whittome also found that, even if discrimination could be inferred, the City was likely able to show non-discriminatory reasons for its decision. The tribunal’s role was to identify discrimination, not reassess the best candidate, adjudicate general management fairness or enforce the collective agreement.



