
A Cranbrook skating club has been ordered to compensate a coach for refusing to renew her contract in retaliation for a human rights complaint, even though her underlying age-discrimination claims failed.
In Flannigan v. Cranbrook Skating Club, 2026 BCHRT 236, issued November 6, the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal awarded Amber Flannigan $918 in lost wages and $5,000 for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect, plus interest. Vice-chair Devyn Cousineau also ordered the club to stop the violation and refrain from similar conduct.
The tribunal found that reserving certain ice time for youth was not discriminatory in the circumstances. The separate protection against retaliation nevertheless applied when the club ended Flannigan’s coaching relationship in 2023.
Dispute over adult access to youth ice
Flannigan, an experienced adult figure skater and certified coach, wanted suitable ice time to practise advanced skills. The non-profit club was Cranbrook’s only provider of Skate Canada programming and rented ice from the city, whose fees and priorities favoured youth recreation.
Beginning in 2019, the club told her she could not skate during youth sessions because admitting adults would trigger higher rental charges. Other adult sessions were less suitable, inconvenient or cancelled for low enrolment. A city official informally suggested an exception might be possible, but that arrangement was never formalized through official channels.
Flannigan challenged the restrictions as age discrimination and alleged that the club curtailed coaching opportunities because of her advocacy. She filed her human rights complaint in December 2021. The tribunal found that the club learned of it in February 2023 and received formal notice that it was proceeding on May 30.
On June 16, 18 days after that formal notice, the club told her it would not renew her coaching contract for the next season.
Age claims failed on the evidence and context
The tribunal distinguished unequal treatment from discrimination. A program directed to youth served a group vulnerable relative to adults and did not perpetuate disadvantage or demean adult skaters. On that basis, it found the age distinction did not require justification under the Human Rights Code.
Alternatively, the club had justified its approach. Letting adults use youth ice would have changed the rental arrangement and increased costs. The tribunal accepted that a volunteer-run non-profit with limited funds could not reasonably be required to raise fees for everyone or find additional funding to serve the very small number of adults seeking advanced ice time.
That conclusion was expressly tied to this case. The tribunal said accommodation for people with disabilities who historically faced recreational barriers could raise different considerations.
The employment-discrimination claim also failed because the evidence did not connect the club’s conduct to Flannigan’s age. The tribunal therefore did not need to decide whether her club and freelance coaching arrangements qualified as employment under the Code.
Contract refusal crossed the retaliation line
Retaliation required a sufficient connection between adverse treatment and an actual or possible human rights complaint. A complainant’s personal perception alone was not enough, but the connection could be inferred where a reasonable complainant aware of all the circumstances would perceive retaliation.
Most of Flannigan’s allegations did not meet that test. Earlier coaching limits arose against pandemic restrictions or lacked sufficient evidence connecting them to a possible complaint. Tense relations, disputes about club representation and restrictions on youth ice did not by themselves establish prohibited retaliation.
The 2023 contract decision was different. Cousineau relied on its timing, the club’s unpersuasive explanation and explicit references to the human rights complaint in its communications about renewal.
The club said Flannigan had not supplied specific coaching availability. But her response was much like those it had worked with in previous seasons. It did not follow up to arrange a schedule or tell her that availability was the reason for refusal. Although a witness said the club needed coaches, it did not explain why it rejected her request for club coaching work.
The club produced no minutes supporting its account of the decision. Its refusal letter identified no reason beyond asserting that the decision was unrelated to the complaint. In context, that denial reinforced rather than dispelled the inference that the complaint was central to its thinking.
Compensation limited to the proven violation
The wage award used Flannigan’s $918 earnings in the previous season as the best measure of what she would have earned if renewed. The tribunal rejected her request for $50,000 in dignity compensation, finding that much of the distress described related to events that did not violate the Code.
It awarded $5,000 for the specific loss of coaching opportunities and the distress of the retaliatory refusal. Coaching mattered to her participation in the skating community, but it was not her livelihood. Pre-judgment interest was ordered on lost wages and post-judgment interest on all amounts.
The result illustrates that a person need not win the underlying discrimination allegation to receive protection from retaliation for bringing it.



