Match MG Field Canada Inc. has won its appeals over the employment-insurance and Canada Pension Plan status of two retail merchandisers, with the Tax Court finding that they worked as independent contractors during the periods in dispute.

In Match MG Field Canada Inc. v. M.N.R., 2026 TCC 194, decided November 5, 2026, Justice Susan Wong allowed the appeals without costs. The ruling covered Victor Peterson’s work from January 1, 2018 to December 17, 2020 and Pamela Pearse’s work from June 23 to August 4, 2020.

The minister had classified the workers as employees in insurable and pensionable employment. The company maintained that they supplied services as independent contractors. The court resolved the dispute through the actual working relationships, not simply the wording of their agreements.

Earlier victory did not settle these appeals

The company first argued that a 2018 Tax Court ruling involving a related Match business prevented the employment-status issue from being litigated again. That earlier case had found two other workers to be independent contractors.

The judge rejected that argument. The workers, periods and duties differed, and it was unclear whether the contracts were the same. The earlier workers were product demonstrators; these appeals involved merchandisers. Those differences went to the substance of the employment inquiry.

Contractual intention had to match reality

The central question was whether each worker provided services as a person in business on their own account. The court considered the parties’ intentions first, then tested those intentions against objective factors such as control, equipment, opportunity for profit, financial risk and the ability to hire help.

Peterson was an experienced merchandiser who signed an independent-contractor agreement and understood the terms of the engagement, even though he did not fully appreciate the technical distinction between employee and contractor. The court found a shared intention that he work independently.

Pearse had previously held a salaried sales role with another Match company. Her evidence confused aspects of that earlier position with the later merchandising engagement, so the judge could not find a common intention about her status. That did not end the inquiry: the objective working arrangements still had to be examined.

Organizing projects was not decisive control

The work involved setting up, stocking and rearranging retail displays according to diagrams specifying where products belonged. Peterson worked at retail locations in New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island and also supplied merchandising services to several other companies.

On individual assignments, workers could arrange their schedules within a completion deadline. Larger projects required teams, with a company supervisor setting a common start time and coordinating the work.

The judge distinguished that coordination from the degree of control associated with employment. Following a display plan reflected the nature of merchandising and the requirements of the brand whose products were being displayed. Business-casual clothing, store sign-ins and identification badges were ordinary professionalism rather than strong evidence of employer control.

Pearse described stricter supervision and an inability to refuse assignments. The court considered her account less reliable because it mixed different jobs and projects. It found that both workers retained the option to decline projects and could set their schedules when working alone.

On the evidence as a whole, the control factor favoured independent-contractor status.

Other factors pointed in different directions

The company supplied the project kits and a simple tool used to adjust displays. Peterson used his own vehicle and electronic devices, and both workers arranged their travel, with mileage reimbursed. Equipment slightly favoured employee status because the company provided the materials needed for each project.

Opportunity for profit and financial risk pointed the other way. Both could work for other businesses, and Peterson regularly did. Hours and workdays varied: accepting more work increased earnings, while refusing it meant losing that income and potentially future assignments.

Neither worker hired helpers. Although the company argued they could do so, the workers did not understand that to be an available option and the contractual wording did not clearly establish it. The judge treated that factor as neutral, rather than accepting the company’s assertion at face value.

Decision limited to the relationships examined

Weighing the factors together, the court found that neither worker was in insurable or pensionable employment with Match during the relevant period. It awarded no costs, explaining that the EI and CPP appeal rules did not provide for them.

The result is fact-specific. It does not make every merchandiser a contractor or establish that signing an independent-contractor agreement determines employment status. The court examined the workers’ actual arrangements and reached its conclusion despite some evidence pointing toward employment.