Cariboo Pulp & Paper Company lost its fair-hearing challenge to a ruling against using excluded supervisors for union first-aid coverage.

In Cariboo Pulp & Paper Company, 2026 BCLRB 346, the British Columbia Labour Relations Board dismissed the application November 10, 2026.

After safety rules increased coverage requirements, the company trained supervisors instead of using Unifor Local 1115 attendants. The agreement restricted supervisors’ performance of bargaining-unit work, permitting temporary assistance without displacement. An arbitrator found a breach and left remedies to the parties.

The November 2024 safety amendments changed both the number of first-aid attendants the mill needed and the level of certification those attendants had to hold. The parties agreed that designated attendant positions belonged to the bargaining unit. On previous occasions when the mill needed more coverage, it had used bargaining-unit employees. This time it counted the newly trained supervisors toward its required complement.

At arbitration, Cariboo argued that supervisors spent little of their shifts treating injuries. The arbitrator heard uncontradicted evidence that an attendant also reviewed records, coordinated with contractors and remained immediately available throughout the shift. Counting only the minutes spent treating an injury would miss what the mill relied on its designated attendants to do.

Applying under section 99(1)(a) of the Labour Relations Code, the company argued the arbitrator invented a certificate-possession test without hearing arguments.

The board said the award expressly rejected that premise: work involved ongoing readiness, inspections and equipment checks. The company itself advanced the certificate argument and had a full opportunity to present its case.

Fair-hearing review concerns process. The board found no dramatically new characterization requiring notice.

The board’s review guidance explains that its authority is limited to unfair hearings and awards inconsistent with labour-law principles. It generally does not revisit factual findings, reweigh evidence or interfere where an arbitrator genuinely tried to interpret the relevant agreement. A successful application can lead to an award being set aside, returned to arbitration or decided by the board.