
The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a complaint about exclusion from a Gabriola Island golf club event because the available evidence did not connect the vaccination requirement to a disability.
The decision is MacLean v. Gabriola Golf and Country Club, 2026 BCHRT 233, published by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal.
Stephen MacLean was refused entry to an indoor open-mic event at Gabriola Golf and Country Club on December 12, 2021. He had neither proof of vaccination nor a medical exemption, as required under the public-health rules then in force.
MacLean alleged discrimination in services under section 8 of the Human Rights Code. He said concerns about vaccination were connected to a disability. The club denied discrimination and applied to have the complaint dismissed before a hearing.
In the November 5 decision, tribunal member Jess Hadley granted the application under section 27(1)(c). That provision permits dismissal where a complaint has no reasonable prospect of success; it does not involve making final findings on contested facts.
The central problem was not simply that MacLean lacked an exemption document. He needed evidence capable of establishing that a disability prevented vaccination, and therefore that disability was a factor in his exclusion from the event.
The medical records he supplied did not identify a disability that prevented him from being vaccinated. His personal concern about possible side effects did not supply the missing evidence.
The tribunal distinguished having a disability in general from showing that a particular disability caused an inability to comply with the vaccination requirement. Even if MacLean could establish a protected disability, that would not by itself connect it to the refusal of service.
Without a reasonable prospect of proving that connection, the complaint could not proceed. The decision is an assessment of the evidence in this case, not a blanket declaration that every vaccination policy or every refusal to accommodate a person with a disability is lawful.
The respondent bore the burden on the dismissal application. The threshold for a hearing was low: the complainant did not have to prove the case at this stage, but the evidence had to move the alleged discrimination beyond conjecture.



