
Inter Pipeline has won permission to appeal a ruling that refused to set aside an arbitration award of approximately $80 million, after arguing that missing disclosure was assessed under an unduly demanding standard.
In Inter Pipeline Ltd v Teine Energy Ltd, 2026 ABCA 355, the Alberta Court of Appeal found a reasonably arguable question about whether the judge reviewing the award had applied the wrong legal test. Justice Karan M. Shaner released the decision on November 4, 2026.
The ruling opens a further appeal of the refusal to set the award aside. It does not itself cancel the award or decide that the arbitration was unfair.
Undisclosed forecasts followed an $80-million award
Teine produces light crude oil in southwestern Saskatchewan and ships it on the Mid-Saskatchewan Pipeline System, owned and operated by Inter Pipeline. The system takes that oil to Inter Pipeline’s terminal for transfer to the Enbridge Main Line and operates under Inter Pipeline’s published tariff.
The companies’ 2014 pipeline connection agreement contained an arbitration clause. Teine began arbitration in May 2022, alleging several breaches of the agreement and tariff, including the use of an improper equalization formula. Inter Pipeline argued that the claim was out of time because Teine knew or ought to have known about the formula earlier.
After a two-week hearing before three arbitrators, the panel rejected that limitation defence in August 2024. It found insufficient evidence that Teine knew or ought to have known of its claims until after the arbitration had begun. The panel found that Inter Pipeline had used the wrong equalization formula and awarded Teine approximately $80 million in damages and interest. It dismissed Teine’s other claims.
Inter Pipeline subsequently sought to set aside the award. In September 2025, it learned through another arbitration between the companies that Teine had not produced forecasts prepared by Boomerang Energy Marketing, even though the records fell within the panel’s production orders.
A judge initially refused to compel their production. The Court of Appeal reversed that ruling, and Teine provided the forecasts. Inter Pipeline then relied on them in its application to set aside the award.
Fairness and effect on the result were separate questions
Inter Pipeline relied on provisions of Alberta’s Arbitration Act addressing manifestly unfair treatment, denial of an opportunity to present a case and procedures that did not comply with the arbitration agreement.
The judge hearing that application asked two questions: whether there was a reasonable possibility that the new evidence would have affected the arbitration’s outcome, and whether there was a reasonable possibility that the non-disclosure had affected its fairness. An affirmative answer to either could justify setting the award aside.
The judge found neither basis established. Among other things, the forecasts alone did not show whether Inter Pipeline had met its contractual obligations, contained information similar to material already disclosed, and did not supply arguments otherwise unavailable on the existing record. The judge also found that Teine’s failure to produce them had been inadvertent.
Inter Pipeline did not challenge how the judge had stated the test. It argued that the analysis actually demanded more: proof that the forecasts were essential to its case, rather than a reasonable possibility that they could have affected the result. It also challenged the judge’s assessment of how the evidence could have been used and the relevance assigned to the inadvertent non-disclosure.
Teine answered that the judge had made factual findings supported by the record. In its view, Inter Pipeline was disputing the language used rather than demonstrating a substantive error, and the proposed appeal could not succeed under the deferential standard applicable to factual findings.
A legal issue, not a decided appeal
Shaner held that Inter Pipeline had shown a reasonably arguable appeal with a possibility of success. Although applying law to facts generally raises a mixed question, an allegation that the wrong legal test was used raises a question of law that does not attract deference.
The permission test also considers the issue’s effect on the litigation, its interest to others and reasons to limit further litigation. Shaner found that deciding whether the judge had imposed too high a standard would matter to the companies and others, given disclosure’s central role in fair proceedings.
Permission was granted on a defined legal question concerning whether a more stringent standard or other separable legal errors affected the assessment of fairness, the opportunity to present a case or compliance with the arbitration agreement. The decision concerns the challenge to the refusal to set aside the award, not a determination of a direct appeal from the award itself.



