
A comedy club’s failure to participate in a human rights hearing did not relieve the complainant of proving his case, the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has ruled in dismissing a complaint about allegedly antisemitic jokes.
The decision is Nitikman v. Otsu Investments Corp dba Comedy After Dark, 2026 BCHRT 232, published by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal.
Joel Nitikman attended Comedy After Dark for his son’s bachelor party in November 2022. He said jokes about Jewish people left him angry and offended, and alleged discrimination in services based on religion and race.
The operator, Otsu Investments Corp., never participated in the proceeding. Tribunal member Edward Takayanagi was satisfied it had received notice and proceeded with the September 16 hearing in its absence. The November 4 ruling dismissed the complaint after hearing Nitikman’s evidence and considering his written closing submissions.
Takayanagi accepted that Nitikman is Jewish and acknowledged the history of stereotyping, marginalization and discrimination against Jewish people. But establishing a protected characteristic was only part of the legal test. Nitikman also had to establish an adverse impact in services connected to that characteristic, on a balance of probabilities.
For most of the jokes, the evidence lacked the actual words. Nitikman recalled feeling demeaned and thought some jokes may have invoked stereotypes, but had not taken notes and could not describe precisely what was said. The tribunal could not assess whether unidentified remarks crossed the threshold into discriminatory conduct.
One remembered comment concerned his son’s mixed Jewish heritage and suggested that it gave him a choice about spending time with the Jewish side of the family. Nitikman regarded that as insulting and as implying that being Jewish was undesirable.
The tribunal assessed that comment in context rather than treating offence alone as decisive. It considered the seriousness of the words, the setting and the history of discrimination against the affected group. The remark arose spontaneously during friendly audience banter, rather than as prepared material. Nitikman also recounted that his son was not offended, although the son did not testify.
Takayanagi found that particular comment, viewed in its circumstances, did not amount to discrimination. That conclusion was separate from the inability to assess the other jokes because their words were missing.
The complaint was dismissed under section 37(1) of the Human Rights Code following a merits hearing, not screened out as merely unlikely to succeed. The ruling does not create general immunity for comedy performances. It turns on what was proved about the actual remarks and their context.



