A B.C. trial court must revisit how much it will cost a former spouse to raise the money he owes under a $1,130,508 family property order. In S.M.A.R. v M.M.A., the Court of Appeal upheld the valuation of the husband’s company shares. The error lay in assuming he could meet the payment from a car and investment accounts worth about half the amount ordered.

The trial judge valued the family property at $2,661,016 after exclusions and ordered an equal division. The husband, identified in the reasons as S.R., would keep his half-interest in a privately held company, valued at $2,407,500. He was to pay M.A. $1,130,508 to bring their shares of the family property into balance.

S.R. argued that the trial judge should have allowed for the tax he would face if he sold his entire holding. An expert jointly retained by the parties had estimated an average tax rate of 27 per cent on that hypothetical transaction. S.R. asked the appeal court to reduce the compensation payment to $436,946.

Justice Mayer, writing for a unanimous panel, said the availability of a tax estimate did not establish that a sale was likely. S.R. accepted the trial judge’s finding that he was highly unlikely to sell his shares, and his evidence described his continuing work to develop the business. Reducing the value of the shares for tax that might never come due could give him more than an equal share. The court declined to make that deduction.

Raising cash to pay M.A. posed a different question. The trial judge had valued S.R.’s car and investment accounts together at $589,056. Even if he used them all, that left $541,452 of the original order to finance. During closing submissions at trial, M.A.’s own counsel had acknowledged that much of the money would have to come from the company.

There was little evidence at trial about what it would cost S.R. to raise the difference. He might borrow, sell some shares or obtain money through a sale of corporate assets. The trial judge had made no findings on those possibilities. The appeal court said the absence of evidence might reflect the difficulty of predicting how the judge would value and divide the property.

By the time the appeal was heard, most of the compensation had been paid. The panel allowed the appeal in part and returned one question to the trial court. It must decide whether to adjust the outstanding balance for borrowing costs, taxes or other expenses S.R. may incur to pay it. The trial court can make a deduction conditional on a cost actually arising, or discount an estimate to reflect uncertainty. The appeal court fixed no new amount.

Read the Court of Appeal’s reasons in S.M.A.R. v M.M.A., 2026 BCCA 435.