A Nova Scotia judge has refused to add a right-of-first-refusal clause to a parenting order, finding that a father's changed work arrangements, reliable care from a grandmother and the risk of increased parental conflict made the proposed change contrary to the child's best interests.

In Marr v. Chaston, 2026 NSSC 346, Justice Daniel Ingersoll also declined to require the father to offer the mother the opportunity to take their son to a scheduled activity whenever he could not facilitate attendance during his parenting time.

The decision is dated November 3, with written reasons dated November 9. It resolves the outstanding right-of-first-refusal dispute, not a separate application to vary the broader parenting order.

A reciprocal proposal after circumstances changed

A September 2025 consent order gave Chrissy Marr primary care of the child and Jared Chaston regular parenting time. The unresolved issue was whether Marr should have priority over another caregiver when Chaston could not personally provide care during his scheduled time.

At an initial hearing in June 2026, Marr relied on Chaston's frequent work travel and raised concerns about a person who could care for the child in his absence. Chaston opposed the clause, arguing that available caregivers were safe and that the additional coordination would increase conflict.

The judge reserved his decision, then reopened the matter to hear evidence about subsequent developments. By the October hearing, Marr sought a reciprocal clause applying to either parent: it would operate if the scheduled parent could not provide care for 24 consecutive hours, or if an absence of any duration required overnight care by someone else. She also sought the opportunity to facilitate activities the scheduled parent could not manage.

Chaston maintained his opposition. He had changed jobs and no longer expected to travel out of town for work. His relationship with the person about whom Marr had expressed concerns had also ended, and that person would no longer care for their son.

Best interests, not an automatic parental priority

Ingersoll applied the Parenting and Support Act's requirement to give paramount consideration to the child's best interests. A right-of-first-refusal clause is a parenting arrangement and must be assessed on that basis.

The reasons recognize that parents must arrange responsible care during their scheduled time, but that third-party care is not prohibited and may be inevitable when parents work. The decision does not rule out first-refusal clauses generally.

The judge reviewed circumstances that can support such an arrangement, including demonstrated cooperation, an ability to manage conflict and consistency in after-school care. Conversely, conflict, potential monitoring of the other parent, dependable support networks and disruption to a stable schedule can weigh against it.

Here, there was no evidence that Chaston would be unable to meet his parenting responsibilities for extended periods. His new job materially changed the circumstances, making much of the evidence about earlier delegations of care irrelevant to the current request.

The judge also did not decide whether Marr's concerns about the former caregiver were well-founded. Because that person would no longer provide care, those concerns no longer determined the issue before the court.

A trusted grandmother and an established routine

The evidence showed that the paternal grandmother provided safe, supportive and loving care. Marr herself sometimes relied on her. The child enjoyed spending time at his grandmother's home, and the relationship provided stability and safety.

Ingersoll found that a first-refusal clause would introduce uncertainty because there was no predictable pattern of future absences. The child benefited from structure and consistency. Maintaining the established arrangement with a trusted caregiver was preferable to unexpected transfers between parents whenever one became temporarily unavailable.

The arrangement also supported the child's relationship with his siblings. Sending him back to his mother instead of allowing him to remain with them at their grandparents' home would reduce opportunities for that bond.

Communication provided another reason to refuse the requested change. Although the parents sometimes communicated successfully, their overall exchanges were difficult and generated conflict. Requiring more contact, disclosure of the father's availability and oversight by the mother was likely to increase frustration rather than serve the child's interests.

The court dismissed the first-refusal request and, for the same reasons, refused the proposed activity-notification requirement. No costs amount was awarded in the reasons. A party seeking costs must file written submissions within 30 days of the decision, with optional replies within 10 days after receiving the other party's submission.

Read the full decision on CanLII.