
Keith Miller filed his claim for a share of family property less than two years after moving out of Beverley Richards’ condo. By then, the deadline had already passed. In Miller v Richards, the B.C. Court of Appeal upheld a finding that the couple had separated in September 2021, nearly four months before Miller left their shared home.
Miller and Richards began living together in a marriage-like relationship in 2012. Miller contributed $1,200 a month toward the mortgage and strata fees on Richards’ condo. They generally paid their other expenses separately and kept their own bank and investment accounts. Miller moved out in mid-January 2022 and started his property claim on December 22, 2023.
For unmarried spouses, section 198(2)(b) of B.C.’s Family Law Act sets a two-year limit from separation for bringing a property division claim. Section 3(4) expressly allows spouses to separate while they continue to live together. A judge can consider what one spouse told the other about a permanent separation and what either spouse did to put that intention into effect.
The trial judge found that shortly after a September 24 dinner with friends, Richards told Miller the relationship was over and asked him to move out. She had already told a friend that they were separating, and calendar entries she made in the following days recorded the end of the relationship. Miller subsequently cancelled a planned trip with friends. By mid-December he had signed a lease for an apartment and paid the deposit.
Miller argued on appeal that the judge had given too little weight to their continued cohabitation and to emails that, in his view, showed they still hoped to repair the relationship. But Richards had asked him to wait until after Christmas to move, and he stayed on briefly to care for her when she was ill. The judge accepted that Richards’ emails conveyed affection even though she had decided to separate. Justice Mayer, writing for the unanimous panel, said the judge could read those messages as an emotional response to the breakup.
The trial judge had considered the evidence Miller relied on, and Miller did not challenge the judge’s assessments of the witnesses’ credibility. The panel declined to weigh the evidence again. It upheld the finding that the separation was permanent on or about September 24, 2021, and dismissed Miller’s appeal.
The trial judge had also said that, if he were wrong about the deadline, he would divide the increase in the condo’s value equally while leaving other assets in each person’s name. That was a hypothetical outcome. The limitation ruling disposed of the claim, so the appeal court did not decide how the property would otherwise have been divided.
Read the B.C. Court of Appeal’s reasons in Miller v Richards, 2026 BCCA 441.



