
Two owners asked for a secret ballot more than two weeks before their strata corporation’s annual meeting. They did not have to ask again when the meeting began, the B.C. Supreme Court ruled in Shen v The Owners, Strata Plan VR2689. The judge found three errors in how the meeting was run. He left its decisions in place and ordered an independent administrator to run the following annual meeting.
The October 3, 2025 meeting had both in-person and online participants. The strata’s bylaw required a secret ballot if an eligible voter requested one. It set no deadline. Justice Branch said advance notice gave organizers time to arrange a way for owners to mark and deposit their ballots privately.
The Strata Property Act says people attending electronically are neither entitled nor required to vote by secret ballot. That exception applied to those participating online. The strata still had to honour the request for the people who came in person.
The strata’s lawyer had also been elected to chair the meeting. Under its bylaws, the president had the first opportunity to chair, followed by the vice-president if the president was unable or unwilling. The strata had shown no evidence that it followed those steps. The judge found the lawyer’s election as chair invalid.
The third error concerned a council candidate standing as the representative of a corporate owner. Nobody had established her authority before she stood for election. The judge said a formal written appointment was unnecessary. Asking the candidate whether she represented the owner and recording the answer could have sufficed.
Together, the errors were significantly unfair. The owners wanted every vote set aside, including the budget approval and council election. The judge found they had identified little concrete harm from those decisions. Invalidating the council could also put a year’s worth of its work in doubt. One owner could bring his proposal for air conditioning back to the membership for another vote.
The judge directed the strata to approach three lawyers the parties had agreed on, in alphabetical order, and retain the first available and willing to act. The administrator’s authority was limited to running the next annual meeting, at the strata’s expense. The owners also received their costs of the petition at the ordinary Scale B rate.



