
The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a passenger’s discrimination and harassment complaint against VIA Rail, finding that the evidence did not connect his removal from a train to his race or religion.
In Stroude v. Via Rail Canada Inc., 2026 CHRT 113, tribunal member Ashley Bressette-Martinez accepted that removing Derek Stroude before his destination was adverse treatment. She also found the incident serious enough to meet the severity threshold for harassment. Both claims nevertheless failed because a connection to a protected characteristic was not established.
The October 9 decision separately rejected complaints about a seating comment and warnings over phone noise. Those interactions did not amount to adverse differential treatment or harassment. The tribunal assessed the events together, finding an escalating response to disruptive behaviour rather than evidence of racial or religious discrimination.
Warnings before the removal
Stroude, a Black man who identifies as Rastafarian, was travelling from Toronto to Montréal on May 18, 2023. He moved from his assigned seat into a vacant, more spacious area. The service manager checked his ticket and pointed out the change, but allowed him to remain there.
Stroude also made phone calls and watched a movie without headphones. The manager warned him twice about noise after complaints from other passengers. Stroude maintained that he was no louder than anyone else and said the manager also told him to turn his phone off.
The tribunal preferred the manager’s evidence that he asked Stroude to turn the volume down, not switch the phone off. That account was supported by contemporaneous notes. It also accepted that the train’s opening announcement instructed passengers to use headphones with electronic devices.
The seating comment was a factual observation about an undisputed move, with no discriminatory language or evidence showing harmful or hostile treatment, the tribunal found. Being unhappy with an interaction did not itself establish adverse differentiation.
The noise warnings likewise reflected repeated complaints and Stroude’s admitted use of his phone without headphones. He apologized when warned. The tribunal did not accept his assessment of his volume as reliable in light of the other evidence. It found neither the comments nor the warnings insulting, degrading or otherwise characteristic of harassment.
Removal was adverse, but the required link was missing
After the second warning, Stroude asked an attendant for the manager’s name. The manager subsequently told him he would be removed. Police escorted him off at Cornwall, Ontario, and he paid for a taxi to Montréal.
Stroude alleged that the manager laughed and waved goodbye through the window. The manager denied doing so. After weighing the conflicting accounts, the tribunal found the alleged mocking was not established.
VIA Rail reviewed the incident the next morning. After Stroude agreed to follow its policies, it allowed him to use his planned return ticket despite the temporary ban associated with removal. He travelled back without incident.
The tribunal accepted that the interrupted journey was adverse treatment: Stroude paid to reach Montréal and did not receive that service. But proving discrimination also required evidence that race or religion was a factor. Discriminatory intent was unnecessary, and a protected characteristic need not be the only factor.
Stroude argued that the incident reinforced stereotypes about Black men and Rastafarians. The tribunal recognized that stereotyping may be unconscious and that discrimination can be proved through inferences. It nevertheless found that his belief about the staff’s motives was not supported by evidence making discrimination more probable than other explanations.
Crucially, it did not treat disruptive behaviour as automatically excluding discrimination. A passenger could be disruptive and still face discrimination in the response. Here, however, the record supported repeated complaints, warnings and opportunities to change the behaviour, without establishing a racial or religious connection.
The harassment claim failed on that same missing connection. Although a single removal was sufficiently serious and severe to fall within the parameters of harassment, that alone did not establish discriminatory harassment under the Canadian Human Rights Act.
Evidence and the final result
The tribunal preferred VIA Rail’s witnesses on disputed details, while accepting that Stroude testified honestly about the overall sequence. It distinguished sincerity from the reliability of particular recollections.
It declined to draw adverse inferences from missing video or additional witnesses. VIA Rail said the train had no surveillance cameras. It also explained why an attendant it had intended to call was unavailable. Stroude could have sought passenger information well before the hearing if he wished to call other travellers.
The tribunal considered the attendant’s reported observations under its flexible approach to hearsay, alongside the manager’s testimony, documentary records and Stroude’s own admissions. It acknowledged the limits of the evidence but found no basis in the record to treat those observations as inaccurate.
Because neither discrimination nor discriminatory harassment was established, the tribunal dismissed the complaint. It did not proceed to a justification defence or an award of remedies.



