Transport Qamutik has lost its challenge to a union’s certification for unlicensed crew aboard its vessel, after the Federal Court of Appeal found the labour board had reasonably explained why the bargaining unit could negotiate collectively.

In Transport Qamutik Inc. c. Syndicat international des marins canadiens, 2026 CAF 163, released September 29, 2026, the court dismissed the judicial-review application without costs. Justice Peter Pamel wrote the unanimous reasons.

One vessel within a seven-ship group

The Canada Industrial Relations Board’s June 19, 2025 order certified the union for unlicensed crew working for Transport Qamutik aboard the Qamutik. Captains, officers, chief engineers and other licensed personnel were excluded.

The ship was part of a seven-vessel fleet. Each vessel was held by a separate company belonging to Groupe NEAS, which managed the fleet with a related company. Transport Qamutik argued that Groupe NEAS was the true employer because it controlled hiring, working conditions and work organization across the fleet.

The company also relied on the seasonal nature of the work. It said crews were laid off at season’s end, with possible recall the following year, and could be assigned to different ships. In its view, those arrangements undermined both the proposed unit and the board’s decision to assess support using crew members who had worked in the season ending in November 2024.

The employment contracts and end-of-season records of employment, however, identified Transport Qamutik as the employer. The board considered the parties’ written submissions and supporting documents before reaching its conclusion. It did not hold an oral hearing or require affidavits, steps the governing legislation did not require in every case.

An appropriate unit, not necessarily the ideal one

The court reviewed the certification decision for reasonableness. The Canada Labour Code requires the board to decide whether a proposed bargaining unit is appropriate for collective bargaining, but that assessment is contextual and carries considerable discretion.

The board does not have to select the most appropriate possible unit. Its task includes creating viable bargaining structures, supporting stable labour relations and respecting employees’ freedom to choose a union. The appeal court emphasized the deference owed to the board’s specialized assessment of those factors.

Transport Qamutik argued that the reasons failed to meaningfully answer its central objections. The court disagreed. On the employer issue, the board had acknowledged the dispute, considered the submissions and identified the contracts and employment records supporting its conclusion. Its reasoning was not simply an unexplained assertion.

Seasonal layoffs did not defeat the continuing link

The board found no evidence that the crew members had lost employee status after the 2024 season. It concluded that they retained a sufficient, continuing connection to the proposed unit.

The court found that conclusion reasonable. The board’s failure to separately address the company’s argument about transfers between ships did not, in this record, make the decision unreasonable.

Once it found that continuing connection, the board exercised its statutory discretion to consider the wishes of workers from the previous operating season. The court found that approach understandable in a seasonal business and consistent with the Code’s support for freedom of association and collective bargaining.

The reasons were concise, but read as a whole and against the record, they explained the certification. The ruling leaves the union’s certification in place. It does not establish that seasonal workers must always be grouped by vessel or that shared corporate management can never affect the identity of an employer.