A Northwest Territories judge has ordered $750 a month in interim spousal support and continued exclusive possession of a home while leaving a fundamental question for trial: whether the parties were spouses under territorial law.

In Beaulieu v. Careen, 2026 NWTSC 57, Justice S.M. MacPherson found a genuine issue to be tried about the nature and duration of Melanie Beaulieu and Harry Careen’s relationship. The September 2 decision addressed immediate financial and housing needs without finally deciding entitlement or the parties’ property rights.

The support begins September 1, 2026. Beaulieu may remain in exclusive possession of the home pending trial or a further court order. Costs of the application were left for the trial judge.

Conflicting accounts required a trial

Beaulieu said the parties had lived together in a conjugal relationship for approximately six and a half years, from late 2018 until summer 2025. She described herself as financially dependent on Careen and said she had looked after the home rather than working outside it.

Careen disputed that account. He acknowledged two non-consecutive periods of a relationship, neither lasting two years on its own. He characterized other periods when Beaulieu stayed in the home as assistance to someone needing accommodation, rather than a continuing spousal partnership.

The distinction mattered because the relevant definition in the Family Law Act includes a person who has lived with another in a conjugal relationship outside marriage for at least two years. The parties disputed whether their relationship met that threshold.

MacPherson emphasized that relationships do not all follow a single checklist. Determining whether a spousal relationship existed required a contextual assessment of the facts, including evidence that could be tested at trial.

Careen pointed to a period when Beaulieu maintained a separate apartment. The judge explained that separate accommodation did not, by itself, establish that no conjugal relationship existed. Nor would significant dysfunction alone rule one out.

Those observations did not resolve the competing accounts in Beaulieu’s favour. The judge expressly left spousal status undecided. Careen’s position raised substantial issues, but they went to the ultimate characterization of the relationship and resulting obligations, which required a full assessment of evidence and credibility.

Immediate need and the benefit of housing

Beaulieu relied on a substantial income disparity: approximately $172,000 annually for Careen and $5,000 for her. Using her proposed relationship duration, she sought support within a Spousal Support Advisory Guidelines range of $1,359 to $1,812 a month. She alternatively argued for some interim support to meet immediate need.

Careen said that overstated any potential entitlement. He disputed some claimed expenses, argued that other funding covered much of her spending, and said any calculation should reflect the shorter periods he acknowledged. He also emphasized the economic benefit she already received from exclusive occupation of the home.

The court accepted that housing was a relevant consideration. By remaining in the residence, Beaulieu avoided the cost of securing alternative accommodation. That benefit had to be considered alongside her limited income and immediate financial needs.

The judge explained that interim support addresses need and economic disparity while a case awaits trial. It does not finally determine the parties’ rights and obligations. The advisory guidelines provided a useful, though non-binding, framework.

Balancing the income disparity, immediate need, housing benefit and genuine dispute over spousal status, MacPherson ordered $750 a month. That was below the range Beaulieu had advanced using her account of the relationship’s length. The trial judge remained free to assess entitlement, needs, means, duration and other relevant considerations on a complete record.

Possession continued while the case proceeds

Beaulieu had effectively occupied the home exclusively since August 2025. An earlier interim order had preserved that position pending argument on this application. The reasons also recorded that Careen had sold the home to a friend in April 2026, after which Beaulieu received a notice to vacate.

For the present application, the judge focused on housing need and the ability to find alternatives. Beaulieu had nowhere else to go and limited means to pay for accommodation, even with support. Careen said he had been staying with others, but the judge found that he had the financial means and support of friends to provide for his own accommodation pending trial.

Both sides were prepared to proceed quickly to trial without extensive pretrial discovery. The existing situation, the parties’ different housing resources and that intention supported continuing exclusive possession.

The ruling did not finally decide ownership, the disputed relationship or long-term support. A separate dispute about utilities and plumbing was being addressed elsewhere in the proceedings. The orders supplied interim financial and housing arrangements while those broader issues remained unresolved.

Source: Beaulieu v. Careen, 2026 NWTSC 57.