
The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld a labour board ruling that no collective agreement was in force during an illegal two-day West Coast port strike in July 2023, rejecting the employers’ argument that the agreement continued to govern their damages grievance.
In British Columbia Maritime Employers Association v. International Longshore & Warehouse Union-Canada, 2026 FCA 136, decided August 7, 2026, the court dismissed the employers association’s judicial-review application. The parties had settled the costs issue themselves, so the court made no costs order.
The ruling does not reverse the earlier finding that the July 18–19 strike was illegal. Instead, it distinguishes the requirements for lawful strike action from the provisions that temporarily preserve an expired collective agreement.
A return to work followed by another walkout
The association bargains for employers involved in national and international marine transportation in British Columbia. The union represents longshore employees at Canadian West Coast ports.
Their agreement expired on March 31, 2023 after the employers gave notice to bargain. Although it prohibited strikes, it contained no bridging clause continuing the agreement through negotiations. The Canada Labour Code nevertheless maintained its provisions during a statutory freeze period.
After the necessary cooling-off period ended, union members began a lawful strike on July 1. At the federal labour minister’s urging, the parties agreed to recommend a mediator’s proposed settlement to their principals. Employees returned to work on July 13 while the proposal was considered.
An internal union committee rejected the proposal, and the strike resumed on July 18 without a fresh 72-hour notice. The Canada Industrial Relations Board ruled that the renewed strike was illegal because another notice was required. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld that finding in a separate 2024 decision.
Why the agreement’s status mattered
The employers filed a grievance seeking damages for the illegal strike. During that arbitration, the union asked the arbitrator to refer the agreement’s status to the board. Section 65 of the Code allows the board to determine a referred question about whether a collective agreement exists.
In its 2025 decision, the board found that no agreement was in force on July 18 and 19. The employers challenged that conclusion, contending that the only reasonable interpretation was that the agreement remained operative.
The distinction mattered to the grievance route. Statutory provisions preserve some arbitration rights after an agreement expires, but they do not necessarily preserve every kind of grievance indefinitely. The earlier appeal had also noted that the employers contemplated a civil action if their damages grievance could not be arbitrated. This decision did not award damages or determine such an action.
The freeze and strike-notice rules are different
Justice Mary Gleason, writing for a unanimous panel, found the board’s interpretation reasonable.
The key provisions tie the statutory freeze and the general continuation of arbitration rights to satisfaction of the requirements in paragraphs 89(1)(a) through (d) of the Code. Those requirements concern notice to bargain, unsuccessful bargaining and the conciliation or cooling-off process.
Separate paragraphs deal with other conditions for a lawful strike, including strike-notice requirements. Meeting the first group of conditions therefore does not necessarily mean every later strike is lawful. Conversely, failing to give a required new strike notice does not automatically revive the expired agreement.
Here, the first group of statutory conditions had already been met. The resumed strike was unlawful because the union failed to provide another notice, not because those earlier conditions remained outstanding. It was reasonable for the board to conclude that the agreement was no longer in force.
The Code expressly preserves a narrower route for arbitration of dismissal or discipline disputes during the gap before a new agreement. The employers’ damages grievance was not such a dispute.
Continuing working terms did not revive the agreement
The employers relied on Supreme Court authority recognizing that terms from an expired agreement may continue to govern an employment relationship. But the appeal court distinguished the continuation of working conditions from the continued legal force of the agreement itself.
The cited case involved different legislation and did not determine whether an agreement survived the expiry of this statutory freeze. Likewise, the board’s return-to-work order directed employees to work under the agreement’s terms and conditions; it did not decide that the agreement remained in force for every purpose.
The court also emphasized the limits of judicial review. A competing interpretation, even a plausible one, would not justify intervention if the board’s actual interpretation remained reasonable. The board had addressed the competing arguments and explained a conclusion supported by the statutory scheme and its previous decisions.
The result leaves intact both findings: the renewed strike was illegal, and no collective agreement was in force when it occurred. The practical lesson is that illegality of a strike does not, by itself, establish that an expired agreement supplies a contractual grievance remedy.



