
The Federal Court of Appeal has largely rejected Viterra Canada Inc.’s challenges to contempt proceedings over excessive weekly work hours at its Vancouver grain terminals, leaving the contempt finding and penalty ruling intact.
In Viterra Canada Inc. v. Grain Workers’ Union (International Longshoreman’s Warehousemen’s Union, Local 333), 2026 FCA 121, dated June 26, 2026, the Court dismissed six consolidated appeals and allowed a seventh only to narrow the scope of a solicitor-client costs award.
The penalty order had imposed a $400,000 fine, subject to adjustment depending on how promptly Viterra ended its contempt. The appeal court found no basis to disturb that penalty. Its limited change concerned costs for two earlier stages, not the fine.
The Court also awarded the union solicitor-client costs for all seven appeals, including the one on which Viterra obtained that limited relief.
From a work-hours grievance to contempt
Viterra operates two grain terminals in the Port of Vancouver. Grain Workers’ Union Local 333 ILWU filed policy grievances in July 2017 alleging breaches of the Canada Labour Code’s maximum-hours provisions.
In 2019, an arbitrator found that Viterra regularly scheduled employees beyond 48 hours a week, contrary to the relevant Code provisions. He ordered the company to stop violating the Code and left the parties to seek an averaging arrangement for their continuous-operation schedule. Those negotiations did not produce an agreement.
The union filed the award in the Federal Court under section 66 of the Code, which gives a registered arbitral order the force of a court judgment. It began contempt proceedings in August 2020. The Federal Court found Viterra in contempt in May 2022 and imposed the penalty a year later.
The seven appeals covered the award’s enforceability, subpoenas, evidence, the contempt finding, penalty, an unsuccessful attempt to demonstrate compliance, and costs associated with compliance applications.
A technical filing error did not invalidate enforcement
Viterra argued that the award could not support contempt proceedings because its filing certificate cited the wrong section of the Code. The appeal court agreed that contempt proceedings require close adherence to procedural safeguards because of their serious consequences. But the registry’s incorrect statutory reference was a technical error that caused no prejudice, not a defect invalidating enforcement.
The Court also rejected the claim that the award merely declared past wrongdoing. Read with the arbitrator’s reasons, it required specific future conduct: Viterra had to stop scheduling employees beyond the weekly limit. Referring to the Code did not make that direction too vague.
Nor did the absence of a fixed compliance date automatically make the order unenforceable. The Court could interpret it as requiring compliance within a reasonable time, assessed in context. That did not remove the union’s obligation to establish contempt beyond a reasonable doubt or allow the Court to rewrite the award.
Corporate employees could be required to give evidence
A central dispute concerned subpoenas requiring two Viterra employees to testify and produce records of hours worked.
Viterra relied on Federal Courts Rule 470(2), which protects a person accused of contempt from being compelled to testify. It argued that compelling its employees and records effectively forced the corporation to testify against itself.
The appeal court held that the rule protects individuals, not corporations. Its purpose reflected the protection against forcing an accused individual to give incriminating testimony, rather than creating a corporate right to silence through employees.
Employees and officers could be compelled to testify where they were not themselves subject to contempt proceedings personally. The two subpoenaed employees were not personally accused. Production of corporate documents through them was not prohibited on the basis advanced by Viterra.
The Court also rejected attempts to raise an abuse-of-process argument without an adequate record showing it had been advanced below, and to revisit a separate production ruling that Viterra had not appealed.
Shift diaries were admissible
Viterra challenged the admission of two employees’ diaries recording shifts and pay entitlements. The workers could not independently remember the hours worked on particular days, but had recorded that information at the end of their shifts to check the accuracy of their pay.
The Court upheld admission under the exception for a recorded past recollection. The relevant memory gap concerned hours worked, not every event that occurred on a particular date. The union did not have to take the witnesses through every entry where their testimony established that they could not recall the daily hours.
The circumstances also supported the reliability of the records: the entries were contemporaneous, concerned discrete information, and served the employees’ strong interest in accurate remuneration. The Court upheld the alternative finding that the diaries were necessary and reliable under the principled approach to hearsay.
The contempt finding and penalty stood
With the subpoena and evidence challenges rejected, the underlying findings about hours worked remained undisturbed. The Federal Court had found beyond a reasonable doubt that Viterra intentionally continued scheduling work beyond the limit.
The evidence also supported the conclusion that Viterra had a reasonable opportunity to comply. The Federal Court found little, if any, effort to do so before 2021 and no evidence that the union obstructed compliance. Negotiations over averaging had ended in May 2020.
On penalty, the appeal court emphasized the deference owed to the sentencing judge. Viterra’s arguments largely asked it to reweigh factors already considered, including prolonged non-compliance, the importance of enforcing labour arbitration awards and the company’s resources.
The Court did not find that employees had suffered proven safety harm. It expressly noted mitigating considerations recognized below: the excess hours were voluntary, employees were fully paid, and there was no evidence of direct harm or that profit directly motivated the conduct. Those factors did not erase the broader public interest in compliance with labour standards and arbitral orders.
Earlier costs rulings could not be replaced
Viterra succeeded on one narrow point. The penalty judge’s award of solicitor-client costs throughout the proceedings could not override earlier costs decisions.
The preliminary order had made no costs award, while the subpoena ruling had awarded costs under the middle column of Tariff B. Those outcomes remained binding. The appeal court therefore excluded those two stages from the later blanket solicitor-client award.
The Court otherwise upheld the costs rulings, including costs for reviewing Viterra’s successful later compliance application. The Federal Court had found that Viterra ended its contempt as of September 3, 2023. The union’s review of the supporting application still assisted enforcement, even though it took no position on that application.
The result confirms the enforceability of this registered labour award and the evidence used to establish its breach. It is not a finding that Viterra remains in contempt today, and it does not turn a technical procedural defect into permission to disregard the safeguards governing contempt proceedings.



