The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the invalidation of Quebec’s 2024 law halting electoral redistribution, finding that the province had not justified suspending the process across Quebec when a narrower measure could have protected Gaspésie.

In Quebec (Attorney General) v. Lalande, 2026 SCC 13, seven judges dismissed the province’s appeal. The court delivered its decision orally on April 22 and released written reasons on May 1. Justice Nicholas Kasirer wrote for the majority; Justices Suzanne Côté and Malcolm Rowe jointly dissented.

The case concerned the constitutionality of the earlier interruption law, not approval of every feature of the map eventually used in the 2026 election. Quebec subsequently enacted different legislation establishing 127 ridings, an important distinction when reading the ruling after the election.

The issue was justification, not a new test for equal voting power

Quebec’s Superior Court had found that stopping the independent boundary-review process infringed the right to vote under section 3 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, at a time when many electors’ voting weight was already diluted. It nevertheless upheld the law as a justified limit under section 1. The Quebec Court of Appeal reversed that result and declared the law unconstitutional.

At the Supreme Court, the attorney general did not appeal the finding of a section 3 infringement. The dispute was whether that infringement could be justified. The majority therefore did not undertake a fresh determination that a particular deviation in the number of electors, by itself, violates the Charter.

The province argued that its law protected regions facing population decline and gave elected representatives time to reconsider the rules governing representation. It also relied on the National Assembly’s unanimous support for the pause and challenged the appeal court’s view that a more limited alternative would accomplish its objectives.

A provincewide halt went further than necessary

Kasirer accepted the immediate, specific objective identified by the lower courts: preventing the disappearance of an electoral division in Gaspésie. He rejected the argument that the Court of Appeal had improperly narrowed that objective. The broader goals advanced by the province—protecting declining regions and allowing time for reflection—were insufficiently precise for the Charter justification analysis.

The majority also questioned how the broader objective could rationally explain stopping revision of all Quebec boundaries, including preserving a division in Montréal. It was the more precise Gaspésie objective that had allowed the lower courts to find a rational connection between the legislation and its purpose.

The decisive problem was minimal impairment. Under the section 1 framework, the government had to show that the chosen measure did not impair the right more than necessary. Courts give legislatures a measure of latitude, but that did not remove the need to justify the breadth of this law.

A less impairing option was available, the majority held: temporarily protect the Gaspésie divisions while allowing the Commission de la représentation électorale to finish its work elsewhere. That could achieve the accepted objective while reducing the dilution of the voting rights of half a million electors and limiting the interruption of the independent process.

Unanimous passage could support a conclusion that an electoral measure was adopted in good faith rather than for partisan reasons. But, Kasirer explained, unanimity did not insulate the law from constitutional scrutiny or discharge Quebec’s burden of demonstrating that it was sufficiently tailored.

Because the law failed at minimal impairment, the majority did not need to address the remaining proportionality arguments. It upheld the declaration that the interruption law was of no force or effect. Quebec had not asked the court to suspend that result. Costs were awarded to the seven respondents identified in the majority’s final paragraph.

The dissent saw a reasonable, temporary legislative choice

Côté and Rowe assumed, without deciding, that the law infringed section 3, but would have held the infringement justified. In their view, the Court of Appeal had recast the legislature’s objectives too narrowly and then evaluated the alternatives against that narrower description.

They accepted two linked goals: preserve representation in regions with declining populations and allow time for a cross-party, longer-term reform. Maintaining the existing map for one additional electoral cycle, they reasoned, protected those regions without shifting the problem to other similarly affected areas.

The dissent emphasized that effective representation combines relative voting equality with geography, community interests and the practical ability of elected representatives to serve constituents. Quebec’s statutory 25 per cent threshold for deviations from the average number of electors per division was not itself a constitutional rule. Nor, in their analysis, did the Charter require an independent boundary-setting process.

The dissenters considered a temporary pause to be within the range of reasonable legislative choices. They said the legislature lacked time to consult, revise the governing criteria and have a new map prepared before the election. They also stressed that selecting among competing models of representation was principally a legislative task, rather than one with a single judicially preferred answer.

In weighing the effects, Côté and Rowe contrasted the large distances and service difficulties in Gaspésie with the comparatively smaller deviations in six of the seven divisions with elector counts above the statutory threshold discussed in the case. They regarded the benefits of temporarily preserving regional representation as outweighing the harms, and would have upheld the law. That view did not command the majority.

The later 127-riding map

Élections Québec’s current official history records a new map established on June 12 under the Loi visant à assurer la représentation effective des électeurs. It preserved the 2017 boundaries of 12 named ridings and otherwise used the boundaries the commission had established in January 2026. The resulting map had 127 ridings and was used for the 2026 general election.

The commission’s June 17 Gazette officielle notice identifies the later statute as 2026, chapter 15 and publishes the 127-riding list. Those later legislative steps should not be confused with the Supreme Court’s adjudication of the 2024 interruption law. The May reasons did not decide the constitutionality of the subsequent statute.

Read the full judgment: Quebec (Attorney General) v. Lalande, 2026 SCC 13. The later map is documented in Élections Québec’s official history and the June 17 Gazette officielle notice.