Newfoundland and Labrador’s fish-harvesters’ union has lost a grievance seeking to include more packaging formats in the sales data used to calculate the 2025 year-end snow-crab settlement price.

In the March 23, 2026 award in Association of Seafood Producers Inc. and Fish, Food and Allied Workers Union, arbitrator Christopher Peddigrew upheld the Association of Seafood Producers’ interpretation: the calculation was based on sales of five-to-eight-ounce snow-crab sections in wholesale 30-pound cases, not sections sold in every packaging format. He had issued his decision without reasons on February 12.

The distinction concerned the sales benchmark, not whether a harvester qualified for a settlement payment. The parties agreed that a processor’s choice to package crab differently did not eliminate its obligation to pay harvesters the year-end settlement. Entitlement depended on the raw material purchased from the harvester, not how that buyer eventually packaged it.

Winning the formula did not settle its meaning

The Fish, Food and Allied Workers Union, or FFAW/Unifor, brought the grievance against the processors’ association and companies listed in the grievance. It said the Standing Fish Price-Setting Panel had accepted a proposal requiring the settlement calculation to include all commercially sold five-to-eight-ounce sections, including consumer packs and cases of other sizes.

Under the statutory process described in the award, the panel selected one party’s proposed crab-pricing formula. Its pricing decision became part of the collective agreement. The panel chose FFAW’s formula for 2025, but the parties later disagreed when preparing instructions for the independent auditor responsible for the settlement calculation.

FFAW argued that its proposal referred to “all receipts” and imposed no restriction based on packaging. Because the panel had selected its proposal through final-offer selection, the union said a 30-pound restriction appearing in the processors’ submission could not become part of the result.

The processors argued that wholesale 30-pound cases were the established pricing benchmark. They said the union’s interpretation would add value from post-processing products to a system designed to determine the minimum price of raw crab bought from harvesters.

Peddigrew rejected the view that choosing a formula meant accepting every aspect of the successful party’s written submissions to the exclusion of the other side’s materials. The legislation required selection of one proposed formula and a decision consistent with that party’s position on price. It did not confine interpretation to the union’s brief.

He treated the dispute as collective-agreement interpretation, considering the pricing decision’s wording alongside the bargaining context, established terminology and the parties’ history.

Destination, not packaging

A central issue was the change from “FOB Boston” pricing in 2024 to “FOB Plant” in 2025. The earlier approach had limited the available receipts to sales delivered to Boston. The new approach was intended to capture sales to other destinations, with freight and duties excluded.

Read in that context, Peddigrew found, the union’s reference to all receipts addressed a destination problem, not a request to include additional packaging formats. He also interpreted the panel’s discussion of agreed definitions as incorporating the 30-pound-case limitation.

The arbitrator found that FFAW had not clearly asked the panel to include consumer packs in the 2025 settlement calculation. Even if the union privately understood its proposal that way, he was not satisfied that it had communicated that understanding to the panel.

The parties’ longstanding reliance on the Urner Barry wholesale pricing index also supported the processors’ interpretation. That benchmark used 30-pound cases. Peddigrew noted the agreed fact that 92 per cent of five-to-eight-ounce sections sold in 2025 were packaged in those cases.

No broader benefit through interpretation

Peddigrew also considered the industry’s commercial structure. The pricing system concerned raw material bought from harvesters, while processors incurred the additional costs and risks of producing consumer packs. The panel had rejected a broader proposal involving all snow-crab products in 2024.

Against that history, he declined to infer a material change in 2025 without a clear statement from the panel. He also found that the union could not obtain a material financial benefit through the grievance that it had not sought during negotiations or before the panel.

The grievance was denied. The award did not calculate an additional payment to harvesters. It provided a conditional 60-day period, running from the parties’ receipt of the award, for further matters concerning interpretation, application or compensation.