
The Supreme Court of Canada upheld an order preventing National Bank from reimbursing Eurobank for roughly US$13.9 million paid to Greece’s defence ministry in a dispute arising from Bombardier’s sale of firefighting aircraft.
In Eurobank Ergasias S.A. v. Bombardier inc., 2024 SCC 11, the court ruled 7–2 that the fraud exception to payment under a letter of credit applied. The majority concluded that the Greek bank knew of and participated in the ministry’s fraud, making that fraud its own for purposes of the Canadian counter-guarantee.
The April 5, 2024 decision clarifies when a bank loses the protection ordinarily afforded to an innocent beneficiary of a letter of credit. It also exposes a sharp disagreement over how Canadian courts should treat foreign judgments governing another part of the same transaction.
Two guarantees behind an aircraft deal
Bombardier’s 1998 agreement to supply Greece with 10 amphibious firefighting aircraft was accompanied by an offsets contract requiring work to be subcontracted to Greek suppliers. Potential liquidated damages for failing to fulfil those obligations were secured by a guarantee issued by a Greek bank.
National Bank, at Bombardier’s request, issued a separate counter-guarantee backing the Greek bank’s payment obligation. The first guarantee was governed by Greek law; the counter-guarantee was governed by Quebec law. The historical conduct described in the reasons concerned Eurobank’s predecessor, although the court generally used Eurobank’s name.
A dispute over the offsets obligations went to arbitration in Paris. Greece’s defence ministry undertook in 2012 not to demand payment while the arbitration continued. It nevertheless called on the guarantee in 2013. An arbitral interim order directed it to refrain from doing so until the final award.
The Greek bank sought an injunction in Greece. Temporary protection ended when a Greek court dismissed its application in December 2013. After the ministry renewed its demand and threatened civil and criminal measures, the bank paid on December 24. A Quebec injunction against payment was then in place.
One week later, the arbitrators declared the offsets contract void from the outset for violating European Union law. Eurobank had already sought reimbursement under National Bank’s counter-guarantee. Quebec courts prevented that payment.
A narrow exception to reliable payment
Justice Nicholas Kasirer, writing for seven judges, emphasized that letters of credit normally operate independently of the underlying commercial dispute. A bank must honour a demand that satisfies the instrument’s documentary requirements, subject to the fraud exception. That reliability lets businesses arrange payment without waiting for litigation over contractual performance.
Fraud remains a high threshold. An ordinary contractual disagreement, or even an absence of good faith, is insufficient. The conduct must involve impropriety, dishonesty or deceit of the kind that makes the demand fraudulent. The court was addressing commercial fraud, not making a criminal finding.
The ministry was a third party to the Canadian counter-guarantee: Eurobank, rather than the ministry, was its beneficiary. That distinction mattered. A third party’s fraud cannot automatically deprive an innocent beneficiary of payment.
The majority required both knowledge and participation. Clear knowledge of obvious fraud must exist before payment, and the beneficiary must take some action involving it in the misconduct. A bank that unknowingly facilitates fraud, or knows about it but does not participate, remains protected. Where both elements exist, the fraud becomes the beneficiary’s own rather than a form of indirect liability.
Why the majority attributed the fraud to Eurobank
The majority found no reviewable error in the trial judge’s conclusion that the ministry engaged in fraud by demanding payment contrary to its undertaking and the arbitral order, shortly before the final award. A breach of contract does not itself establish fraud, but its circumstances can supply the necessary impropriety.
The bank’s employees testified that they knew the arbitral tribunal had prohibited the ministry from demanding payment. They also knew the final award was imminent. For the majority, this supported the trial finding of clear knowledge rather than mere suspicion. Paying in those circumstances constituted participation.
Eurobank argued that Greek courts had upheld the ministry’s right to demand payment. Those judgments included a Hellenic Supreme Court decision released after the Canadian appeal hearing and admitted as fresh evidence.
Kasirer said the Greek judgments had not been formally recognized and made enforceable in Quebec. They could be considered as evidence, including prima facie proof of reported facts and the proper application of Greek law, but did not bind Quebec courts. Their evidentiary weight attracted appellate deference.
The majority upheld the decision to give them no weight, stressing the concern raised by allowing a party to disregard an arbitral order despite agreeing to the arbitration process. It likewise gave the new Greek Supreme Court judgment no weight. The issue was the fraud exception under Quebec law governing the Canadian counter-guarantee, not whether the ministry had committed fraud under Greek law. No application to recognize and enforce the Greek judgments was being decided.
Eurobank’s duress argument also failed. The trial judge had found its decision voluntary: the bank chose between competing commercial and legal risks. The majority left open whether duress could excuse conduct under the fraud exception in another case.
Dissent said the Greek decisions could not be ignored
Justice Suzanne Côté, joined by Justice Andromache Karakatsanis, would have allowed the appeal and dismissed Bombardier’s action against Eurobank and National Bank.
Côté said the Greek judgments were factual constraints explaining the parties’ conduct, even without formal recognition in Quebec. There was nothing in those judgments that needed enforcement in Quebec. Comity and Quebec’s evidence rules required courts to account for their effect; public-order concerns did not justify revisiting their merits or treating them as irrelevant.
She also rejected the finding that the ministry’s demand was fraudulent. Its undertaking preserved legal rights and anticipated a prompt end to arbitration, whereas Bombardier later introduced a new issue that delayed proceedings. In her view, the undertaking had been validly withdrawn. Breach of the arbitral interim order was contractual, and the Quebec injunctions were not enforceable in Greece. The eventual award and the ministry’s subsequent refusal to repay could not retrospectively establish fraud at the time of payment.
Even assuming the ministry had acted fraudulently, Côté considered the bank innocent. It had sought relief from the competent Greek court and lost. That decision prevented a finding that it had clear or obvious knowledge of fraud, and its compliance with the guarantee did not amount to fraudulent participation. Shifting the commercial loss to the bank would upset the parties’ agreed allocation of risk.
Contract invalidity left unresolved
Bombardier alternatively argued that the invalid offsets contract also invalidated the counter-guarantee. Kasirer declined to decide that unsettled question because the fraud exception disposed of the appeal. He corrected the suggestion that the arbitrators had invalidated the guarantee itself: their award concerned the offsets contract and its relevant provisions.
Côté would have rejected the alternative argument. The bank’s independent obligation survived the underlying contract’s nullity, and the arbitral award had not yet been issued when payment was made.
The appeal was dismissed with costs payable by Eurobank. The result preserved the injunction against National Bank’s payment under the counter-guarantee; it was not an order directing Greece to repay the funds. The Supreme Court docket records the appeal’s closure on March 19, 2026, following taxation of costs.
Source: Eurobank Ergasias S.A. v. Bombardier inc., 2024 SCC 11.



