Ontario’s Divisional Court has quashed a family’s appeal from an eviction order but given them nearly two months to find another home. The tenants argued that a filing problem kept a basement lease out of evidence and that their landlords wanted them out because they had challenged how utility bills were shared. Justice M. Labrosse found no question of law that would allow the court to revisit the Landlord and Tenant Board’s decision.

In Ouazzani et al v. Banda et al., the court lifted the stay that arose when the tenants appealed. The landlords can take steps to enforce the order, but those steps cannot take effect before January 7, 2027. The judge cited the difficulty of finding a home for a large family during the winter holidays and said the timing would allow the tenants to sign a new lease for January 1.

The board’s April 7 order had ended the tenancy on two grounds, the landlords’ intention to occupy the home and substantial interference. It also directed payment of utility charges. The tenants sought a review at the board, which upheld the principal findings. When the tenants appealed, the landlords moved to quash. Section 210 of Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act allows an appeal from the board on a question of law. It gave the court no authority to decide afresh whose account of the landlords’ motives to believe.

The missing basement lease

The tenants said a problem with the board’s online portal or their PIN prevented them from uploading documents about a separate basement lease. They wanted to use the material to challenge the landlords’ intention to move in and to explain a municipal bylaw dispute about the basement. An agent represented the tenants at the hearing. The record suggested they referred to the documents, but the judge found no indication that they asked for another way to file them or sought an adjournment to do so.

The board’s review decision addressed the filing issue. Labrosse also explained why the lease itself was peripheral. The tenants’ lease had originally made them responsible for all the utility bills. The parties later agreed to a 70–30 split. The basement tenant moved out after the additional dwelling unit was deemed illegal, but a separate lease for that unit had no apparent bearing on the agreement to share the bills. On this record, the judge found no procedural unfairness.

Why the landlords wanted possession

The tenants argued that the board had overlooked two reasons the eviction might have been retaliatory. They had complained to a government authority, and they maintained that they had tried to enforce their rights over the disputed utilities. They said the board had put too much weight on the timing of the eviction notice.

The board had also heard that one of the landlords had to return to in-person work in Ottawa. It accepted the landlords’ account that they needed the home and rejected retaliation as the reason they sought possession. It was unclear whether the tenants had separately raised their attempt to enforce their rights under section 83(3)(c) at the board. Either way, Labrosse found that the board’s decision on motive answered both arguments.

The board had also considered whether the eviction should be refused or delayed. It weighed the landlord’s need for the premises against the difficulty of moving a large family and had already granted the tenants some extra time. The judge found it was unnecessary for the board to recount every element of the parties’ dispute when explaining that decision.

What remained open about the utility bills

The tenants also invoked section 138 of the Act to challenge the utility arrangement. Labrosse found the provision mentioned in their supplementary notice of appeal, but saw no indication they had raised it at the board hearing or on review. Assessing compliance would require factual findings, including facts relevant to any time limit on a tenant’s claim. The board had made a finding about what the parties agreed to pay. The tenants had supplied no factual basis for deciding the separate statutory issue on appeal.

The judge left open whether the tenants could pursue reimbursement through another proceeding. The board’s order remained in effect. Costs were left for written submissions.

Read the Divisional Court’s reasons on CanLII.