Joseph Melo collected the rent on a Toronto investment property for more than three decades, though he shared title equally with his former partner, Karen Harris. In Harris v. Melo, the Court of Appeal for Ontario held that his uninterrupted receipt of the rent kept the ten-year deadline for his ownership claim from starting. By the time the judges heard the appeal, the property had sold. Their decision would determine how to divide the proceeds.

Melo and Harris bought the building in 1989, when they were dating. Melo’s intended business partner had pulled out. Harris agreed to take a half interest on title and co-sign the mortgage. Melo supplied the down payment. Their relationship ended the following year, but Melo continued to manage the property and collect all the rent. The court found no evidence that Harris had helped pay the mortgage or maintain the building.

Harris applied in 2023 for an order to sell the property. Melo asked the court to declare that she held her half in trust for him. The application judge found that Harris had given Melo notice by 1995 that she considered herself entitled to her share. Counting ten years from that point, the judge dismissed Melo’s claim as late and ordered a sale. He also found that, had Melo brought his claim in time, he would have established sole beneficial ownership.

On appeal, Melo raised a provision of Ontario’s Real Property Limitations Act that neither side had argued before the application judge. Under section 5(1), when a claimant has possessed the land or received its rent, losing that possession or ceasing to receive the rent can start the clock. Harris acknowledged that Melo had always received the rent. The panel held that her assertion of ownership had therefore never started the limitation period. It rejected her argument that the provision applied only to people claiming land by adverse possession.

Harris had not challenged the judge’s finding that she held her registered interest in trust for Melo. The appeal court set aside the judgment and declared Melo the beneficial owner of her interest. With the property already sold, the judges saw no need for an order changing title. They ordered Harris to pay Melo $22,500 in appeal costs and $28,445.85 for the original proceeding.

Read the Court of Appeal for Ontario’s reasons, 2026 ONCA 798.