A Nova Scotia father has been denied an interim suspension of notices restricting his access to school property, despite raising arguable questions about their legality. The court found no admissible evidence of irreparable harm and separately concluded that the balance of convenience favoured leaving the restrictions in place while judicial review remained pending.

In Green v. HRCE, 2026 NSSC 348, Justice Frank Hoskins dismissed Kelsey Green's stay motion on November 6. The decision did not determine whether the protection notices were valid or whether his judicial review application was filed in time.

Green sought to suspend notices issued under Nova Scotia's Protection of Property Act affecting two schools. The current notice was scheduled to expire on November 26, 2026. The judge treated the possibility of future notices as speculative, rather than extending the analysis to a restriction that had not been issued.

An ordinary stay test, despite the family connection

Green argued that the restriction prevented him from attending his daughter's school events and basketball games. The education centre's evidence described escalating behaviour, including a livestreamed interaction with a principal that raised safety and privacy concerns.

The Halifax Regional Centre for Education urged the court to apply the modified stay test used in cases concerning a child's custody, access or welfare. That approach concentrates on whether granting or refusing a stay better serves the child's interests, with particular attention to stability.

Hoskins instead applied the ordinary framework from Purdy v. Fulton Insurance Agencies Ltd. Although the daughter's interests were engaged, this was a challenge to a property-protection notice, not a private family law or child-protection proceeding.

The ordinary test required an arguable issue, irreparable harm if a stay was refused, and a balance of convenience favouring relief. The cited framework also recognizes a route for exceptional circumstances making a stay fit and just. The court's analysis addressed the three ordinary branches.

The judge also rejected HRCE's proposed reliance on factual findings from 16 earlier written decisions, mostly involving Green and his former wife. HRCE had not participated in those proceedings, and Hoskins found that the principles governing the proposed use of earlier findings were not engaged in these circumstances.

Questions worth hearing were not enough

Green identified questions about whether a public-school occupier's notice could be judicially reviewed, whether reasons were required and sufficient, whether the restriction was overbroad, who had issued it and when the time limit for seeking review began.

Hoskins found those questions met the low threshold of an arguable issue. HRCE's argument that the application was frivolous or vexatious relied primarily on affidavit passages that had been struck and the earlier family proceedings the judge had declined to use.

The ruling acknowledged legitimate concerns about timeliness but left them for the judge hearing the judicial review. Finding an arguable issue meant the application warranted adjudication; it did not establish that any notice was unlawful.

The evidentiary gap on harm

The motion failed on irreparable harm alone. Hoskins emphasized that harm must be established through evidence, not assertion or speculation, and assessed in the circumstances rather than solely by asking whether money could compensate for it.

At the October 9 hearing, the parties agreed to withdraw hearsay affidavit evidence that might have supported irreparable harm, particularly to Green's daughter. For Green, the disputed hearsay was admitted only to explain his behaviour and why he sought a stay. That limited use did not establish the alleged harm.

After reviewing the remaining evidence, the judge found no admissible basis for concluding that either Green or his daughter would suffer irreparable harm if the stay were refused.

The restriction also had a limited remaining duration. Green's own materials acknowledged that he could attend basketball games at other schools. Nothing in the evidence suggested the notice prevented contact with his daughter outside school, subject to existing parenting orders or arrangements.

The court was not satisfied that the temporary inability to attend school events amounted to harm that could not be remedied if Green ultimately succeeded on judicial review.

School safety supported keeping the status quo

Although the lack of irreparable harm disposed of the motion, Hoskins separately considered the balance of convenience and found that Green also failed that branch.

The judge accepted HRCE's position concerning principals' duty to maintain a safe and orderly learning environment and the conduct underlying the notices, including unannounced attendance, refusals to leave, livestreaming around minors and harassing communications.

Against those concerns, the prejudice to Green was limited and temporary and did not prevent an outside-school relationship with his daughter. A stay would suspend a protective notice before its validity had been decided. The balance therefore favoured maintaining the status quo.

The stay was denied. The reasons made no costs order and left the judicial review itself unresolved.

Read the full decision on CanLII.