The Nunavut Court of Appeal has upheld disputed rules for managing polar bear harvest credits, rejecting arguments that they unlawfully interfered with Inuit harvesting rights under the Nunavut Land Claims Agreement.

In Qikiqtaaluk Wildlife Board v. Government of Nunavut, 2026 NUCA 5, the court dismissed a challenge to counting bears killed in defence of life or property against harvest allocations, resetting unused credits when a new total allowable harvest is established, and requiring additional review for certain credit requests.

The September 25 ruling preserves the challenged decisions but does not end discussions about changing the system. The court emphasized that wildlife management involves continuing dialogue among treaty partners and that its judgment was not the final word on how polar bear harvesting should be managed.

Eight requested credits became six

The Qikiqtaaluk Wildlife Board and Sanikiluaq Hunters & Trappers Association challenged the Polar Bear Harvest Administration and Credit Calculation System, known as HACCS, and a decision applying it to Sanikiluaq’s request for harvest credits.

Under that system, communities receive a base allocation from a polar bear subpopulation’s total allowable harvest. Their annual recommended quota is adjusted for previous overharvesting and accumulated credits. Credits arise when a community does not use its full annual quota and may be used later with the required approvals.

In March 2022, the regional board approved Sanikiluaq’s request to use eight credits. The government said the request exceeded the applicable 25 per cent threshold and required review by the Nunavut Wildlife Management Board for potential conservation concerns. It offered to forward the request for review or authorize six credits without that step.

The organizations accepted six without giving up their right to challenge the decision. Their judicial review application was dismissed, leading to this appeal. The dispute concerned the Southern Hudson Bay polar bear subpopulation, from which Sanikiluaq members harvest.

Treaty rights within a shared management system

The appeal court applied the correctness standard to questions about the interpretation and scope of treaty rights. It recognized the agreement as a modern treaty protecting constitutional rights, interpreted in accordance with the honour of the Crown and its text, broader objectives and overall structure.

The organizations argued that the lower court had reduced the treaty to a mere decision-making process. The appeal court rejected that reading. Viewed as a whole, the earlier reasons recognized a wildlife management regime and Inuit rights while explaining that more detailed, adaptable instruments supply matters such as precise annual harvest numbers. The judge had not treated the organizations as mere stakeholders rather than rights holders.

The court also distinguished two concepts. The total allowable harvest sets how many animals may legally be harvested. The basic needs level reserves animals for Inuit harvesting needs as the first demand on that total. For polar bears, Inuit are presumed to need the entire allowable harvest, and the circumstances allowing that presumption to be rebutted were not engaged. The terminology therefore made no practical difference to the quantity available in this case and disclosed no reviewable error.

Regional and community organizations nevertheless argued that, once needs levels were set, their authority over allocation was exclusive and unused credits could not expire. The court disagreed. Their treaty responsibilities complement the wildlife management board’s role rather than displace it. They allocate and manage harvesting among their members within allotments established and administered under the treaty regime; the government retains ultimate responsibility for wildlife management.

Emergency kills can still count toward allocations

The treaty allows a person to kill wildlife when necessary to preserve human life or protect property, notwithstanding other provisions of its wildlife article. The organizations argued that this protection also prevented such kills from reducing harvesting entitlements.

The court drew a distinction between the individual’s right to act in an emergency and the accounting consequences for the wider harvest. The provision protects necessary defensive killing from being prohibited by Article 5. It does not say that an animal killed for that reason must be excluded when allocations are calculated.

Other treaty language expressly addresses the disposal of valuable parts of animals killed in emergencies, but does not prescribe how those kills affect harvest allotments. That silence, together with the conservation objectives and shared responsibilities of the treaty, supported the court’s interpretation.

The wildlife management board had recognized the concern that safety-related kills could reduce opportunities to harvest for cultural, social and economic purposes. It approved the system while recommending further work on an acceptable accounting approach. The appeal court left alternative methods for the partners to discuss.

Why unused credits can be reset

The organizations characterized accumulated credits as unused basic needs entitlements that could not lawfully be confiscated. They also argued that resetting them on the date of a new total allowable harvest decision was arbitrary.

The court rejected both arguments. Credits did not belong exclusively to regional and community organizations beyond the continuing management regime. More specifically, HACCS explained the conservation reason for resetting them: bears left unharvested are already reflected in updated population estimates through their effects on population growth or decline. Preserving old credits alongside a new harvest calculation could count the same animals twice.

The mechanism also accounts for changing reproduction, survival and environmental conditions. Credits accumulated during population growth could have a different effect if used during decline. Linking the reset to a new harvest decision was therefore neither unnecessary nor arbitrary on the arguments before the court.

That conclusion did not remove the treaty’s limits on decision-making. Restrictions must remain necessary for a valid conservation purpose or another recognized objective, and the partners could explore other mechanisms.

Review is not an automatic refusal

Neither side identified record evidence explaining why 25 per cent was selected as the threshold for wildlife management board review. Even so, the court declined to find the threshold unlawful: it triggers scrutiny rather than automatically refusing the additional credits.

An actual authorization decision must assess the conservation concerns and evidence existing at the time. The requested credits may still be granted. The organizations’ further argument that the board lacked authority to review credit use repeated their rejected claim to exclusive control.

Finally, the court rejected the complaint that the lower judge had wrongly characterized their position as requiring agreement before action. Although counsel had not used the word “veto,” the submissions sought consensus before decisions could be taken. The characterization caused no legal error.

The appeal was dismissed. HACCS remained open to review at a partner’s request, and the court stressed the continuing responsibilities of those involved in the treaty relationship.

Source: Qikiqtaaluk Wildlife Board v. Government of Nunavut, 2026 NUCA 5.